Comment: Hosepipe bans and a cost of living crisis – it’s time to talk about water
It’s been one of the driest winters on record. Drought orders are already being issued.
By Gavin Shuker
But all this is happening against the backdrop of a quiet water affordability crisis. Like most things, until something goes wrong, few question the shape of the water industry. Despite the British obsession with complaining about the weather, we’re now experiencing drought. And we know the problem will only get worse over the next thirty years.
Published last year, the Water White Paper is the government’s plan to reform the water industry. It faces up to the long term challenges of competition, harmful abstraction,
metering and climate change. But on one issue it is silent.
It’s the issue that matters to customers most – a plan to keep our water affordable.
Instead of bringing forward plans to tackle affordability or deal with the sustainability of water resources, the Government has tabled a short bill to deal with the specific issue of high water costs in the South West.
The Bill will enable the Government to make a £50 payment to households in the South West to reduce their water bills. Whilst this is a welcome initiative to tackle the legacy
costs from privatization on the region, it does nothing to deal with rising bills elsewhere in the country.
The South West has the highest bills in the country, including around 200,000 household which are paying more than 3% on their water bills, or under what is defined within the
industry as water poverty. Yet there are one million people paying more than 3% of their income on water in the Thames region alone.
The cost of living crisis is affecting households now. From April water bills will raise by 5.7% or about £20 per year. But the Government is not accepting any responsibility. Instead they are taking a hands-off approach, leaving it to water companies to design their own affordability schemes, and even giving them the choice to provide it or not.
The Government had promised to publish a draft Water Bill in the spring bringing together affordability, sustainability and business competition issues in the water sector. It is now widely acknowledged that Defra has failed again, and that we won’t see any legislative reforms this year. This means we won’t see any serious action on water from this Government until two-thirds of parliamentary time is already used up. Even normally mild mannered Tory MPs are getting hot under the collar, with Anne McIntosh pressing the point at PMQs last month.
Ultimately, we should be working towards extending help through a national affordability scheme – so your ability to pay isn’t determined by your postcode.
With changing weather patterns and increased pressure on water resources this is not an issue that is going away. Following the 2008 floods, Labour brought together a cross-party consensus to speed up reform in the water sector, leading to the Flood and Water Management Act (2010). Over the last 18 months the Government has squandered that legacy and torn up the consensus on water reform.
It is not good enough to sneak through legislation just dealing with one region. We will use the forthcoming Water (Financial Assistance) Bill to raise wider concerns about rising
bills and affordability faced by households across the country; and urge the Government to think again about delaying wider water reforms.
When Cameron attempts to dodge the big questions on water and make affordability the responsibility of the big society, we will expose it.
Gavin Shuker is the shadow water minister
The opinions in politics.co.uk's Comment and Analysis section are those of the author and are no reflection of the views of the website or its owners.