Tony Benn was a leading figure on the left of the Labour Party and one of the most influential British politicians of the post-war era.
First elected to parliament in 1950, Benn’s early activism secured the passage of the Peerage Act 1963, allowing him to renounce his peerage and sit in the House of Commons after being temporarily disqualified from sitting.
Benn served in the governments of Harold Wilson and James Callaghan, holding posts including postmaster general (1964-1966), secretary of state for industry (1974-1975) and secretary of state for energy (1975-1979).
Benn’s experience of government radicalised him, and he emerged in the 1980s as a prominent advocate of democratic socialism. A central figure in Labour’s internal struggles, Benn contested the party leadership in 1976 and deputy leadership in 1981.
After losing his Bristol seat in the 1983 general election, Benn returned to parliament via a by-election in Chesterfield in 1984. He remained an influential voice on the Labour left, and in 1988 challenged once again for the Labour leadership.
Benn stood down from parliament in 2001 after more than 50 years of service. He continued to be an active political campaigner, including as a prominent opponent of the Iraq War as president of the Stop the War Coalition (2001-2014).
Throughout his political career, Benn maintained a meticulous daily record of his experiences, which eventually formed The Benn Diaries, published in nine volumes between 1987 and 2013.
Benn died on 14 March 2014 at the age of 88.
Benn was first elected to parliament as the MP for Bristol South East at a by-election on 30 November 1950. He succeeded Stafford Cripps, the chancellor from 1947 to 1950, who stood down due to ill-health. The result marked the first of four by-election victories for Benn in the course of his 50-year parliamentary career.
Benn, who was 25-years-old upon his election and the youngest MP, sat as the “baby of the House” (1950-1951 and 1951-1954).
On 1 November 1956, Benn vehemently criticised the government’s conduct during the Suez Crisis.
He told the House: “Egypt… was attacked, and under Article 51 [of the United Nations charter] she has the undoubted right to defend herself. What do the British government do? They send Egypt an ultimatum, telling her to desist from the right of self-defence.”
Benn was a prominent figure during the 1959 general election campaign. Drawing on his radio experience, Benn oversaw a series of 12 party broadcasts.
In the wake of the 1959 general election, which resulted in a majority Conservative government under Harold Macmillan, Benn was appointed to his first frontbench post in the shadow transport team.
Benn actively supported the 1963 Bristol bus boycott, declaring that he would “stay off the buses, even if I have to find a bike”.
In November 1960, Benn’s father, William Wedgwood Benn, the 1st Viscount Stansgate, died. Benn’s ambitions and politics were very much linked to his presence in the commons, but upon inheriting his father’s peerage, his seat was automatically declared vacant.
Benn’s father had not anticipated that his heir apparent, Michael (Benn’s elder brother), would pursue a career in the House of Commons. However, Michael was killed in action during the Second World War, leaving Benn as the successor to the title.
Benn was dubbed the “reluctant peer” by the press – a phrase he loathed. He preferred to be known as the “persistent commoner”.
On 13 April 1961, the House debated a motion to allow Benn, the 2nd Viscount Stansgate, to address MPs from the bar of the House. Hugh Gaitskell, the Labour leader of the opposition, argued that there was “no single case in the history of the House of Commons where a member whose right to sit has been in dispute… has been refused” the opportunity to speak. He referred to the cases of Daniel O’Connell, a Catholic, and Charles Bradlaugh, an atheist, who faced comparable obstacles in the 19th century and both addressed MPs from the bar of the House before taking their seats.
R.A. Butler, the home secretary and commons leader, led the government in opposition to the motion, asserting that Benn had “ceased to be a member of this House on the death of his father on 17 November, 1960.”
The motion to hear Benn was subsequently defeated by 221 votes to 152, and MPs went on to consider the finding of the commons privileges committee that “peerages cannot be surrendered.” The committee cited the opinion of John Doddridge, a former justice of the king’s bench, who in 1626 held that a peerage is “a personal dignity annexed to posterity and fixed in the blood.” The House endorsed the committee’s report by 204 votes to 126, resolving that Benn was indeed disqualified from membership.
The writ was formally moved for a by-election in Bristol South East on 18 April.
Benn stood to fill the vacancy created by his viscounty in the 1961 Bristol South East by-election. He placed first, winning 23,275 votes (69.5%) on a swing of 13.3 points from the Conservatives. His rival candidate, Malcolm St Clair, won 10,231 votes (30.5%).
Benn’s re-election in Bristol South East, however, had no bearing on his legal disqualification to sit in the commons.
On 8 May 1961, Benn returned to the commons to take the oath of allegiance. He was confronted by the House doorkeeper and told that the commons speaker, Harry Hylton-Foster, had “given instructions that physical force should, if necessary” be used to prevent him entering.
Benn addressed the House in a letter, calling on the speaker to “countermand” his order. He requested the opportunity to address MPs at the bar of the House to explain “why I should be permitted to take the oath following my election by an overwhelming majority of the people of Bristol South East, whose servant I am.”
The House divided and rejected Benn’s request by 250 votes to 177.
MPs then approved Butler’s motion that “the said Anthony Neil Wedgwood Benn, otherwise Viscount Stansgate, be not permitted to enter the chamber unless the House otherwise orders” by 254 votes to 160.
This development coincided with Malcolm St Clair, the Conservative runner-up in the 1961 Bristol South East by-election, initiating formal proceedings to challenge the result. An election court ultimately ruled against Benn, who represented himself in the case (Re Bristol South-East Parliamentary Election), and the seat was awarded to St Clair.
St Clair, therefore, won the 1961 Bristol South East by-election with a majority of -13,044 over Benn – on a swing of -13.3. The disqualified Labour incumbent lost with 69.5% of the vote. Technically, he would have lost with 100% of the vote.
Benn, meanwhile, launched a campaign to force a change in the law. His agitation ultimately provoked the Peerage Act 1963. The act, which received royal assent shortly after 06:00 pm on 31 July 1963, enabled hereditary peers to disclaim their titles for their lifetime within 12 months of inheriting them (or within 12 months of the act for existing peers).
Benn was the first peer to renounce his title under the Peerage Act 1963, doing so at 06:22 pm on 31 July. St Clair, who was himself the heir to a peerage, stood down as the MP for Bristol South East to trigger a second by-election. Both the Conservative and Liberal parties stood aside.
The result, delivered on 20 August 1963, was a resounding victory for Benn. He secured 20,313 votes (79.7%) – a majority of 15,479 over Edward Martell in second place. Martell, one of three independent candidates who challenged Benn, stood on a “National Fellowship Conservative” platform.
On 24 October 1963, Benn delivered his first commons speech since his re-election as the MP for Bristol South East. He notably declined to ask for the traditional “indulgence” of the House to deliver a maiden speech, stating: “I have been elected three times to this parliament and I have sat in this House before.”
The Labour MP thanked his constituents “without whose loyalty I would not be in this House today – quite unaided by the serried ranks opposite.”
In the wake of the 1964 general election, which returned a Labour government under Harold Wilson, Benn was appointed as postmaster general. In this role, he oversaw the opening of the Post Office Tower and introduced commemorative postage stamps.
Benn was appointed as minister of technology in July 1966. He left this post after Labour’s defeat in the 1970 general election.
Benn served in the shadow cabinet from 1970 to 1974. During this time, he established himself as an opponent of Britain’s accession to the European Economic Community (EEC), the flagship policy of Edward Heath’s Conservative government. His campaigning helped persuade the Labour leadership to support an amendment to the European Communities Bill proposed by anti-EEC Conservative MP Neil Marten calling for a referendum on British entry.
Roy Jenkins, the deputy Labour leader, viewed this move as a concession to his party’s anti-EEC, eurosceptic wing and resigned. He was joined in his resignation by two further senior shadow ministers, George Thomson and Harold Lever. In his resignation letter, Jenkins opposed what he called “government born out of opportunism.”
Benn was appointed to the cabinet as secretary of state for industry after the February 1974 general election returned a minority Labour government. He served as secretary of state for energy, his last government post, from August 1975 to May 1979.
Benn was a prominent figure in the 1975 EEC referendum. This vote, the country’s first-ever nationwide referendum, was called by Harold Wilson as prime minister largely to resolve Labour’s internal divisions over Europe. During the campaign, the normal rules of party politics were summarily suspended. Wilson granted his ministers a rare “agreement to differ”, summarily cancelling collective responsibility. In the end, of the 23 members of Wilson’s cabinet, seven did not support the government’s pro-EEC position.
On 26 April 1975, a special one-day conference of the Labour Party voted decisively for the United Kingdom’s withdrawal from the EEC. The position was carried by 3,724,000 votes to 1,986,000 – almost a 2:1 margin. Speaking after the vote, Benn commented: “We have had a conference and the decision is clear… It is very clear that there now must be a move for the Labour Party to campaign.”
Benn was the spiritual leader of the official “No” campaign, formally the National Referendum Campaign (NRC). During the campaign, Benn delivered the contested claim that being in the EEC had cost the country half a million jobs. Roy Jenkins, the home secretary and spiritual leader of the “Yes” campaign, dismissed the suggestion in a press conference of his own. “I find it increasingly difficult to take Mr Benn seriously as an economics minister”, Jenkins stated.
On 2 June 1975, Jenkins and Benn clashed in a BBC Panorama TV debate. The debate, watched by a reported 8 million people, represented a more sober discussion of the merits of the campaign.
In one exchange, Benn argued that EEC membership meant surrendering the liberty to decide Britain’s policies through the ballot box in return for economic gain. Jenkins pushed back, drawing a distinction between “sovereignty” and “liberty”.
Benn responded: “We give up the liberty to decide our policy through the ballot box in pursuit of some economic advantage.”
The industry secretary also expanded on his claim that 500,000 jobs had been lost as result of Britain’s membership of the common market. He argued that all the evidence “of our eyes confirms it in the Midlands, in Merseyside, in Scotland and elsewhere, that common market membership has been a disaster.”
He added: “Our future lies, as we’ve argued, it does, in increasing our trade with the rest of the world.”
Jenkins rejected Benn’s argument as “nonsense”.
He stated: “How Tony Benn can discuss these issues of jobs and employment without any regard either to the blow to the prosperity of the Western world as a whole as a result of the oil prices, or without any regard at all to the dangerous rate of inflation in this country, I do not know.”
The referendum result represented a resounding endorsement of EEC membership. A full 67.23% voted in favour of staying in, versus 32.77% who supported withdrawal. Every administrative region of the UK voted “Yes”, with the exception of the Shetland Islands and the Western Isles.
Benn responded: “When the British people speak everyone, including members of Parliament, should tremble before their decision and that’s certainly the spirit with which I accept the result of the referendum.”
On 16 March 1976, Wilson announced that he was resigning as prime minister – a decision that took the country and most of his cabinet colleagues by complete surprise. The shock departure triggered the 1976 Labour leadership contest.
The 1976 Labour leadership contest is remembered today for its display of considerable political talent. The roster of candidates, Benn, Jenkins, Denis Healey, Anthony Crossland, Michael Foot and James Callaghan were all heavyweight figures in their own right. Both Benn and Jenkins withdrew from the contest after its first round on 25 March, after securing the support of 56 and 37 Labour MPs respectively.
Callaghan triumphed after defeating Foot on the third and final ballot with 176 votes. Benn endorsed Foot after withdrawing from the contest.
In his acceptance speech, Callaghan paid tribute to Wilson, but asked for the party to “wipe the slate clean”. He took on Labour’s factions, declaring: “If we work together as a team, we shall be unbeatable. I want no cliques. There will be no insiders and no outsiders.”
The new prime minister retained Benn’s services as industry secretary.
In 1976, the Labour government’s slim parliamentary majority was gradually eroded by a run of by-election losses. Callaghan initially sought to remain in office through an agreement known as the “Lib-Lab Pact”.
On 28 March 1979, having chosen to put off an autumn election, Callaghan soon found the issue forced upon him. The Labour government lost a confidence motion by one vote. The 1979 general election produced a Conservative majority, and the first female prime minister in British and European history, Margaret Thatcher. Callaghan stepped down as Labour leader in 1980.
Benn’s experience of government, including the International Monetary Fund (IMF) emergency loan (1976) and the Winter of Discontent (1978-1979), shifted his politics markedly to the left.
When Callaghan stepped down as Labour leader in 1980, Benn did not stand in the consequent contest. Rather, he criticised those who put their names forward, arguing that no election should take place until the party had agreed on a new method for choosing its leader. Delegates at Labour’s recent autumn conference had called for a special gathering to agree these procedures.
The 1980 leadership contest took place against the backdrop of a widening divide within the Labour movement, between an insurgent and increasingly influential grassroots current – associated with Benn – and the social democratic tradition associated with figures like Callaghan and Denis Healey.
Michael Foot prevailed in the 1980 Labour leadership election after defeating Healey in the final round. Foot was firmly identified with the party left. But he was well-liked by Labour MPs and seen as capable of uniting the party. A non-tribal, conciliatory figure, he served loyally in both Wilson and Callaghan’s cabinets – including as deputy leader since 1976. The white-haired socialist elder statesman hence emerged as a compromise candidate.
Grassroots pressure for procedural change culminated at the dramatic Wembley conference in January 1981. The leadership election procedure agreed by delegates apportioned the vote between the trade unions/affiliates (40%), the constituency parties (30%), and the Parliamentary Labour Party (PLP) (30%).
This vote represented the final impetus for the creation of the Social Democratic Party (SDP). The famous “Limehouse declaration” (January 1981) was issued as an immediate reaction to the rule changes agreed at Labour’s Wembley conference. “The calamitous outcome of the Labour Party Wembley conference demands a new start in British politics”, the declaration began.
Over the course of 1981, 28 Labour MPs defected to the SDP – which now threatened to “break the mould” of British politics.
In 1981, Benn challenged Healey, the incumbent deputy leader, under the party’s new procedures.
The long campaign over the course of 1981 was bitter and divisive. It consumed Labour, meaning the party mostly failed to capitalise on Margaret Thatcher’s lagging position in the polls. The SDP-Liberal Alliance, meanwhile, soared above Labour and the Conservatives to occupy first place.
Benn was denounced by some on the Labour frontbench for the way he went about the campaign. In September 1981, the Labour chief whip, Michael Cocks, said a Bennite victory would be “little short of a disaster.” Cocks, who was supporting Healey, said that “there is a basic distrust, however unfounded, amongst most Labour voters about both Mr Benn’s motives and those of his supporters.”
In the first round of voting, the race’s third candidate, John Silkin, was eliminated. Silkin secured 18.0% of the electoral college vote; Healey and Benn stood on 45.4% and 36.6% respectively. The final ballot proved incredibly close. Benn secured an overwhelming majority of the constituency party vote (81.1%). But Healey secured a commanding majority of the PLP (65.9%) and the heavily weighted trade union/affiliated bloc (62.5%).
On 27 September 1981, Healey was re-elected as deputy leader of the Labour Party, prevailing with just 50.4% of the electoral college vote.
A crucial factor in Healey’s victory was the decision of approximately 20 MPs from the Tribune Group, including Neil Kinnock, to abstain. These Tribune Group MPs – said to represent the ‘soft left’ – voted for Silkin in the first round but absented themselves in the second. Kinnock, the shadow education secretary, said he had refused to vote for Benn as he stood “for victory in the next general election”. The future Labour leader also said he expected to lose his seat on the national executive committee (NEC) as retribution for his abstention.
This split prompted committed Bennites to form the Campaign Group/Socialist Campaign Group.
Despite Benn’s defeat, the Labour conference in Brighton advanced the adoption of a left-wing programme. The 1,300 delegates voted to outlaw private schools, to nationalise most banks and financial institutions, and to reject a mandatory policy of wage restraint. A measure to pay all 16 to 19-year-olds, whether they had jobs or not, was also approved. Some of these measures, or moderated versions of them, would later find a place in Labour’s 1983 election manifesto.
In the immediate term, Benn’s defeat intensified rather than resolved Labour’s internal conflict. Some of Benn’s supporters said they would urge the leading left-winger to challenge Healey again the following year.
In any case, Benn’s narrow defeat was ultimately interpreted as a moral victory by the Labour left. Benn confided in his diary that he entered the Brighton conference hall on 27 September 1981 “prepared for a massive defeat”. The result effectively guaranteed that factional conflict would persist within Labour for the remainder of the 1980s.
For the right of the party, Healey’s victory was considered crucial in preventing a full-scale takeover by the Bennites. Contemporary commentators suggested that a defeat for Healey could have triggered a further exodus of MPs to the SDP. Tony Blair, prime minister from 1997 to 2007, later remarked that Healey’s 1981 victory “probably saved the Labour Party as an instrument of government”.
In November 1981, Michael Foot announced he would not vote for Benn in the shadow cabinet elections, stating he could not trust him to uphold collective responsibility. The electorate for the shadow cabinet was, at the time, confined to the PLP. The announcement followed a commons debate on North Sea oil where two separate positions were set out by Labour frontbenchers. The party’s energy spokesperson, Merlyn Rees, had opened the debate entirely on-message. He stated that a future Labour government would “restore the assets to public ownership on terms that will ensure that no private speculative gains are made at the nation’s expense”.
Benn, closing the debate from the Labour frontbench, described the “reacquisition of public assets without compensation” as “the policy of the Labour Party”. He added that the party’s “long-term policy” was to “bring all oil into public ownership, including BP”. This strategy, the former peer said, would be “buttressed by price controls, exchange controls, the planning of our trade, and withdrawal from the common market”.
This policy discrepancy was seized upon by government ministers, including the newly appointed energy secretary, Nigel Lawson.
Lawson responded: “[Benn] has committed his party to re-nationalisation without compensation of all assets that are privatised and to the total nationalisation of the oil companies and a number of other things.”
He added: “Is that the position of the opposition? Is that the policy of his right honourable friends on the opposition frontbench?”
Foot described the situation as a “shambles”. He said that a commons debate “that should have concentrated our attack on the Tory policy about North Sea oil was transformed by Tony Benn into a quarrel about our own policy on the issue of compensation.”
Benn responded by defending his actions. “I will not allow the shadow cabinet to silence me or anybody else on policies the party has agreed”, he stated. The Labour MP confirmed he was standing for the shadow cabinet to “make it absolutely clear that if I am elected, I would want to be free to speak up for our policies – on Europe, on jobs, on defence, on peace”.
Benn ultimately lost the 1981 shadow cabinet election. He had previously replaced Bill Rodgers, one of the “gang of four”, around the shadow cabinet table. However, the size of Benn’s vote among his PLP colleagues was reported as a “blow” to Foot.
In January 1982, responding to news that unemployment had risen above three million for the first time since the 1930s, Benn accused the government of using the “dole queue and the statute book to prevent organised workers even from sustaining their present standard of living.”
The 1981 deputy leadership election ultimately represented the high-water mark of Bennite influence within Labour – a level of left-wing prominence not surpassed until Jeremy Corbyn’s election as leader in 2015.
Foot led the Labour Party into the 1983 general election, which Thatcher called some 11 months early to capitalise on her newfound popularity following the Falklands War (1982). Labour campaigned on a left-wing platform that included unilateral nuclear disarmament, withdrawal from the EEC, the abolition of the House of Lords, higher personal taxation for the rich, and a sweeping nationalisation programme. The party’s 1983 general election manifesto, entitled The New Hope for Britain, was famously described by one of its own MPs, Gerald Kaufman, as “the longest suicide note in history”.
The split in the anti-Conservative vote – between Labour and the SDP – allowed the Tories to win numerous seats on a minority vote share. Despite a slight fall in the Conservative vote share to 42.4%, therefore, Thatcher’s party gained 47 seats, finishing with a total of 397 and a majority of 144 – the largest since Labour’s victory in 1945. The Sun newspaper referred to “Maggie’s Massacre”.
Labour was reduced to just 209 seats (down 60), the party’s worst result since 1935. Its share of the vote – just 27.6% – was the lowest since 1918.
Benn was defeated in Bristol East, a seat he had held since 1963, ruling him out of the leadership contest that followed.
Foot resigned as Labour leader, and Healey as deputy leader. They were succeeded by the “dream ticket” of Neil Kinnock and Roy Hattersley respectively in October 1983.
Benn returned to the commons after winning the 1984 Chesterfield by-election, winning a majority of 6,264 over the Liberal candidate in second place.
Benn was a strong and vocal supporter of the miners’ strike (1984-1985). He introduced the Miners’ Amnesty (General Pardon) Bill in June 1985, which called for amnesty to all miners imprisoned during the strike.
Kinnock led Labour into the 1987 general election.
Labour won 229 seats and 30.8% – an improvement on the party’s historically poor performance in 1983. However, Kinnock was unable to prevent a Conservative majority and unseat Thatcher as prime minister. The party’s subsequent policy review was regarded as heretical by the left-wing Campaign Group for its ideological concessions.
On 23 March 1988, Benn announced he would challenge Kinnock for the leadership of the Labour Party. Upon launching his campaign, Benn argued that Kinnock’s leadership was abandoning core Labour principles. He pointedly described his platform as a “campaign for socialism”.
The former cabinet minister said he had been urged to stand because the country was in “a period when socialist ideas have been attacked and some people have dropped them.” His aim, he said, was “to put socialism back on the agenda.”
Setting out his stall, Benn declared: “While we go on worshipping profit and neglecting need, and prattling endlessly about productivity, competitiveness and economic efficiency, we’re missing the central point – which is whether we want to be a community of independent people, or driven back to the jungle where the strongest devour the weakest. That is the central question.
“And the raising of these moral questions, and a decision to place them in the forefront of political debate is the most urgent single task the Labour movement faces.”
At the same time, Eric Heffer, a left-wing ally of Benn’s, announced he would challenge the incumbent, Roy Hattersley, for the deputy leadership of the party. In a joint statement, Kinnock and Hattersley dismissed the contest as “futile and selfish”.
They said: “When the priority of the huge majority of the Labour movement is to combat the Tory offensive against the health service and the poor and to secure support for our campaigns for jobs and justice, these people have chosen to turn inwards.
“Only our foes will be pleased and everyone with any sense knows it.”
At the time, Robert Worcester, a Labour pollster, predicted a landslide Kinnock victory, but warned of a six-month “kamikaze campaign” conducted by Benn’s supporters. In an interview with the Independent, Benn warned that without a “socialist alternative on offer”, anxiety could drive voters further to the right. He expressed his nervousness that Labour policy reviews appeared to be shifting the party “closer to the Thatcher position at the time the Thatcher position is beginning to fail.”
Benn’s challenge was considered to be unpopular with the majority of the parliamentary party, who saw it as damaging Labour’s electoral prospects. But Benn, who had threatened to run annual leadership challenges, argued that “division can be healing”.
The election itself took place on 2 October 1988, at the opening session of the Labour Party annual conference. It resulted in an overwhelming victory for Kinnock, who secured 88.6% of the electoral college vote to Benn’s 11.4%. Kinnock won the support of 183 MPs, while Benn secured the backing of just 38. In the deputy leadership contest, Hattersley was re-elected.
Speaking to BBC Newsnight shortly before the declaration of the result, the left-wing Labour MP and future party leader, Jeremy Corbyn, said Benn’s campaign achieved a “degree of activity and discussion of socialist values”. Corbyn, the secretary of the Socialist Campaign Group, argued that the campaign would “result in stronger socialist policies in the long-run”.
Benn was in attendance for the March 1990 anti-“poll tax” demonstration, which descended into some of the worst rioting seen in the capital for a century. The poll tax, introduced under the Local Government Finance Act 1988, was a flat-rate levy on every adult regardless of income. The scheme meant, in the words of Conservative minister Nicholas Ridley, that a “duke [could] pay more than a dustman”. In his famous diaries, Benn said that “before I was due to speak the rally was stopped because of the trouble that had occurred.”
Benn added: “I got off the platform and began walking back down Whitehall but found the police had thrown a barrier across the road so that people couldn’t get up or down, though they let me through.
“In the crowd I found myself being pressed from behind by riot police and mounted police. People were terribly frightened. I forced my way through until I came to the line of police who didn’t look like police at all.”
In 1990, Benn introduced the Margaret Thatcher (Global Repeal) Bill which he said would “reverse the policies and replace the personalities – the process has begun – but the rotten values that have been propagated from the platform of political power in Britain during the past 10 years will be an infection – a virulent strain of right-wing capitalist thinking which it will take time to overcome.”
In June 1991, Benn introduced the Commonwealth of Britain Bill, which called for a constitutional overhaul and codification, for the first time. The bill proposed abolishing the monarchy and the House of Lords, fashioning a “house of the people” to replace the upper chamber, disestablishing the Church of England, and establishing a new “Commonwealth of Britain” with a president serving as head of state. It also called for lowering the voting age to 16, a federal framework, and granting the constituent nations of the UK a right of secession. The bill was seconded on introduction by the future Labour leader, Jeremy Corbyn.
Kinnock led the Labour Party into the 1992 general election. The result, a fourth consecutive Conservative majority, confounded pollsters and precipitated Kinnock’s resignation. Hattersley also resigned as deputy leader in the wake of the election campaign.
Benn was re-elected to parliament as the MP for Chesterfield at the 1997 general election with a majority of 5,775 votes. He emerged as a critic of Tony Blair’s premiership, despite supporting measures such as the national minimum wage, and later described New Labour as a “new political party”.
Benn endorsed John Prescott in the 1994 Labour leadership election.
Benn opposed the Social Security Act 1998, which implemented the abolition of the lone parent premium and one parent benefit. Addressing the commons on 10 December 1997, Benn contrasted the measure with the 1945 Labour government, which had tripled the “widow’s pension from 10 shillings a week to 26 shillings a week”.
Benn stated: “I must say, very respectfully, that the government have not taken a hard decision; they have taken the easiest decision possible, hammering the poorest people who have no bargaining power…
“We are going back to the Victorian concept of the deserving poor, who want work, and the undeserving poor, who prefer to look after their children.”
Benn was one of five Labour MPs, including Jeremy Corbyn, Bernie Grant, John McDonnell and Dennis Skinner, to vote against the Social Security Bill at third reading.
A veteran backbench MP, Benn opposed the 1998 bombing of Iraq and the 1999 Nato bombing of Yugoslavia
In a speech to the House of Commons on 17 February 1998, Benn delivered a famous speech in opposition to a government motion which expressed support for the use of “all necessary means” to ensure Iraq’s compliance with the destruction of chemical, biological and missile weapons facilities.
Benn began by reflecting on a “unique debate”. He said he could not remember an occasion when the “government asked the House to authorise, in a resolution, action which could lead to force.”
In his address, Benn argued that every MP who voted in favour of the government’s motion would be accepting personal responsibility for the deaths of innocent civilians.
In the speech’s most famous passage, he told the House that he lived in Millbank tower during the Blitz. “I saw Dockland burning – 500 people were killed in Westminster one night by a land mine”, he said. “It was terrifying.”
He added: “Aren’t Arabs terrified? Aren’t Iraqis terrified? Don’t Arab and Iraqi women weep when their children die? Doesn’t bombing strengthen their determination?
“What fools we are to live in a generation for which war is a computer game for our children and just an interesting little Channel 4 news item.”
Benn, with future Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn sat over his right shoulder, warned his colleagues that every MP who voted “for the government motion will be consciously and deliberately accepting the responsibility for the deaths of innocent people if the war begins as I fear it will.”
Benn concluded by referencing the United Nations charter and its determination to “save succeeding generations from the scourge of war”.
The Labour MP declared: “That was that generation’s pledge to this generation, and it would be the greatest betrayal of all if we voted to abandon the charter, take unilateral action and pretend that we were doing so in the name of the international community.”
The government motion was agreed by 493 votes to 25.
Corbyn, Diane Abbott, Ken Livingstone, John McDonnell, Dennis Canavan, Dennis Skinner and George Galloway were among the Labour MPs to vote to reject the motion. Benn and Tam Dalyell were the tellers for the noes.
Operation Desert Fox, the US-led bombing campaign intended to degrade Iraq’s ability to manufacture and use weapons of mass destruction, began later that year. The four-day bombing campaign lasted from 16 to 19 December 1998.
Benn sponsored the Military Action Against Iraq (Parliamentary Approval) Bill, introduced to parliament in January 1999 by Dalyell. It called for a simple majority vote in the commons to authorise any future strikes or military action.
In June 1999, Benn announced that he would stand down from parliament at the 2001 general election.
He told the BBC: “I am not retiring from politics, but I believe the work that needs to be done now to rebuild the Labour Party is best done from outside.
“If you are in parliament at the moment you are asked to do a lot of things that run absolutely contrary to the pledges I gave my constituents and to my own convictions.”
Benn added: “I’m not old Labour, I’m a member of the Labour Party.”
In December 1999, Benn supported a Liberal Democrat amendment to the Representation of the People Bill to lower the voting age to 16.
Benn was nonetheless aligned with Blair in his opposition to electoral reform and proportional representation. He rejected the recommendations of the “Jenkins commission” during a debate in November 1998, arguing that the strength of the British electoral system lay in the direct accountability between MPs and their constituents – whom he referred to as “our employer”. Benn argued that pre-election coalitions (those formed within the Labour and Conservative parties) were “transparent”, ensuring “people can see them developing and know what they are voting for and what their own member thinks”.
From 1999 to 2001, Benn was joined in the House of Commons by his son, Hilary.
Benn served as president of the Stop the War Coalition following its founding on 21 September 2001.
The coalition was founded in the weeks following 9/11, when the US president, George W. Bush, announced the “war on terror”. It grew into a broad alliance of anti-war organisations to campaign against the impending war in Afghanistan. The coalition’s single, overriding objective in late 2002 and early 2003 was to prevent the government from committing UK forces to a US-led invasion.
On 15 February 2003, Benn addressed what is believed to be the largest political demonstration in British history, as over one million people marched through central London to protest against the prospect of a war with Iraq. The event was part of a coordinated global day of action that reportedly saw over 20 million demonstrate in cities worldwide.
Benn told the crowd: “We are here today to found a new political movement worldwide – the biggest demonstration ever in Britain.
“The first global demonstration. And its first cause is to prevent a war against Iraq. It must also be about other matters as well. It must be about the establishment of a Palestinian state.”
He added: “While we are here, 35 million people die every year of hunger. While 500 billionaires have the same income as half the population of the world put together. That the world in which we live is dominated by the military, the media and the multinationals.
“And what we are about is getting democracy all over the world. So we can build a world that is safe for our children and grandchildren. That is what it is about.”
Other speakers included Liberal Democrat leader Charles Kennedy, mayor of London Ken Livingstone, Labour MPs Corbyn and Galloway, former cabinet minister Mo Mowlam, actor Tim Robbins, playwright Harold Pinter, human rights campaigner Bianca Jagger, and the American civil rights leader and former presidential candidate, the Rev Jesse Jackson.
The demonstration did not achieve its aim of preventing military action. The House of Commons voted in favour of authorising military action the following month, and the invasion of Iraq began on 20 March 2003 – just 33 days after the Stop the War Coalition demonstration.
From 2003 to 2012, Benn remained a prominent activist and commentator, appearing as guest on political programmes and hosting shows in his own right.
Benn endorsed John McDonnell in the 2007 Labour leadership election.
In 2008, Benn endorsed the independent candidacy of David Davis in the Haltemprice and Howden by-election. Davis, who placed second in the 2005 Conservative leadership contest, triggered the by-election after Gordon Brown’s Labour government narrowly won a commons vote (by a margin of nine) to extend the maximum pre-charge detention period for terror suspects from 28 to 42 days. Davis, a libertarian Conservative, viewed the government’s proposals as a dangerous expansion of state power.
Labour did not stand a candidate in the Haltemprice and Howden by-election.
In an article for the Daily Telegraph, Benn argued that “Libertarians from the Left and Right sometimes meet in the middle against an authoritarian state.” He drew a parallel between Davis’ stand and his own experience seeking re-election to parliament after being unseated upon inheriting a hereditary peerage following his father’s death.
He wrote: “For many years the Labour government has boasted about the traditional values and freedoms of this country; and yet, when its MPs voted to amend the Terrorism Act and permit 42 days in prison without charge, they effectively repealed Magna Carta…
“If the Lords, as expected, also rejects 42 days, it would be a constitutional outrage to use the Parliament Act to enforce the will of the Commons on the second chamber.
“It is on the single, but vital, issue of civil liberties that I decided to support David Davis.”
Benn endorsed Ed Miliband in the 2010 Labour leadership contest.
Benn suffered a stroke in 2012, spending much of the following year in hospital.
Benn died at his home in London on 14 March 2014 at the age of 88.
David Cameron, the prime minister, described Benn as a “magnificent writer, speaker, diarist and campaigner, with a strong record of public and political service. There was never a dull moment listening to him, even when you disagreed with everything he said.”
Ed Miliband, the Labour leader of the opposition, called Benn an “iconic figure of our age”.
Miliband said: “Tony Benn spoke his mind and spoke up for his values. Whether you agreed with him or disagreed with him, everyone knew where he stood and what he stood for.”
A special House of Commons debate was held on 20 March 2014 so MPs could formally pay tribute to Benn.
Nick Clegg, the deputy prime minister, referred to Benn’s “kindness, charm and sense of humour.”
He added: “Many of the battles Tony Benn fought were very much of their time, such as for renationalisation and turning back the tide of globalisation. Yet on so many other issues, Tony Benn was far ahead of his time.
“This includes his passionate commitment to protect civil liberties, promote equality and secure political reform in Britain; I could have done with him being here when we last discussed House of Lords reform. His campaign against Britain’s membership of the European Union – something I, of course, did not agree with him on – will loom large in this year’s European elections.”
Conservative MP Edward Garnier referred to the election of Benn’s son, Hilary, to the House of Commons in 1999.
Garnier told the House: “I remember… when [Tony Benn] stood at that dispatch box with his son, introducing him to this House. The sheer pride of a father for his son was palpable. That is evidence, it seems to me, that we were looking not just at the typical two-dimensional modern politician but at the three-dimensional transparent decency of a very great man.”
Hilary Benn paid tribute to his father in an emotional address.
He said: “He was barred from entry to the Chamber on the instructions of the Speaker because, it was alleged, his blood was blue. His blood was never blue; it was the deepest red throughout his life.”
Hilary Benn added: “He loved this place, the people who built it and those who help us in our work. He loved the debate and the argument. But he did not idealise parliament. He saw it as the means to an end: to be a voice for the movements outside these walls that seek to change the world for the better, as well as being a voice for the people who send us here and whom we all have the privilege to represent.
“That was the essence of his character. Yes, it was shaped, as we have heard, by events and experiences but also, as for many of us, by his childhood. He was, at heart, not just a socialist; he was a non-conformist dissenter.”
On 2 December 2015, Hilary Benn delivered an impassioned commons speech, arguing in favour of extending British airstrikes against Islamic State into Syria. The shadow foreign secretary’s intervention from the opposition dispatch box, which followed 10 hours of debate, was received with rare applause from MPs across the chamber. In response, Alex Salmond, the former Scottish first minister, claimed that Tony Benn – a totemic figure on the anti-war left – would be “birling in his grave” at his son’s advocacy for military action.
Salmond told LBC Radio: “[Hilary Benn] appealed to a lot of traditional Labour buttons but I will tell you this, his father, whose speech I heard, in the Iraq debate all those years ago and I was sitting virtually in the same place.
“His father would be birling in his grave hearing a speech in favour of a Tory prime minister wanting to take the country to war. And that is just the reality.”
Hilary Benn dismissed Salmond’s comments as “pretty cheap”.
Anthony Neil Wedgwood Benn was born on 3 April 1925 in a Victorian house in Millbank, Westminster.
His father, William Wedgwood Benn, was elected as a Liberal MP in 1906. He defected to the Labour Party in 1927 and served as secretary of state for India from 1929 to 1931. He was raised to the peerage as Viscount Stansgate in 1942, and served as secretary of state for air from 1945 to 1946.
Due to his father’s political activities, Tony Benn met Ramsay Macdonald, the first Labour prime minister, when he was five years old. Benn also met David Lloyd George, the prime minister from 1916 to 1922, when he was 12.
Benn attended Eaton House day school and Westminster School. He studied philosophy, politics and economics at New College, Oxford. During his time at university, Benn served as president of the Oxford Union (1947).
During the Second World War, he enlisted in the Royal Air Force as an aircraftsman 2nd Class. He served as a pilot officer in South Africa and Southern Rhodesia.
Benn then took a job in radio broadcasting as a BBC Radio producer.
Benn met Caroline Middleton DeCamp in 1949 at Worcester College, Oxford, and they married later that year.
Benn was diagnosed with chronic lymphatic leukaemia in 1990. He kept his medical condition a secret from the public until 2002. Caroline Benn died of cancer on 22 November 2000, aged 74.
Tony and Caroline had four children: Stephen, Hilary, Melissa and Joshua.
Hilary and Stephen have both sat in the Houses of Parliament. Hilary as an MP, and Stephen as the 3rd Viscount Stansgate. Stephen was elected unopposed to the House of Lords on 10 July 2021, under the curious hereditary peer by-election process, filling the vacancy left by Lord Rea’s death in 2020.
The Benn political family has achieved the unique distinction of having a member serve in every Labour cabinet to date.
Hilary Benn served as secretary of state for environment, food and rural affairs under Gordon Brown (2007-2010). Under Tony Blair, he served as secretary of state for international development (2003-2007), having previously been minister of state (2003) and parliamentary under-secretary of state (2001-2002) in the same department.
Hilary Benn was appointed as secretary of state for Northern Ireland following the 2024 general election, which returned Labour to power after 14 years in opposition.
Benn employed a teenage Ed Miliband to make tea in his office.
Benn strongly identified with the cause of the Levellers, the radical 17th century movement.
In 1976, Benn delivered a speech on “Levellers Day” (17 May) at the Burford Church, referring to the debt owed to the mutineers and their political allies.
Benn said: “The elimination of the Levellers as an organised political movement could not obliterate the ideas which they had propagated. From that day to this, the same principles of religious and political freedom and equality have reappeared again and again in the history of the labour movement and throughout the world”.
In 1979, Benn unveiled a plaque commemorating the “three levellers” – Cornet Thompson, Corporal Perkins and Private Church – at Burford parish church.
In a Guardian article, published May 2001, Benn wrote: “The wording of Clause IV in the modern Labour Party constitution, now dropped in the hope of electoral gain, can be traced back to [the Levellers]…
“Looked at today, all these ideas have a special relevance and it is not difficult to identify what the Levellers might be saying to this generation when the divine right to rule has merely been transferred from the palace to Number 10 Downing Street and crown prerogatives are still used to make our laws in Brussels without the necessity of parliamentary approval.”
Tony Benn has not written for Politics.co.uk.