Opinion Former Article

MDU welcomes government review of manslaughter cases following Dr Bawa-Garba case

The MDU welcomed today’s announcement by Jeremy Hunt of a ‘rapid review’ into the application of gross negligence manslaughter in healthcare.

Announcing a government review in the House of Commons, Jeremy Hunt said the review would examine ‘how we ensure there is clarity about where the line is drawn between gross negligence manslaughter and ordinary human error in medical practice so that doctors and other healthcare professionals know where they stand with respect to criminal liability or professional misconduct.’

Dr Matthew Lee, professional services director, said:

“Although we did not represent Dr Bawa-Garba we recognise the strength of feeling this case has evoked throughout the medical profession.

“We welcome this announcement and agree wholeheartedly that action is needed to provide clarity and restore the confidence of front-line doctors. We have been pushing for fundamental change in this area for some time and we hope that the outcome of this review leads to changes that promote a culture in the health service that is not one of fear and blame but one of fairness, transparency and learning from mistakes.”

Ian Barker, MDU senior solicitor who has represented many doctors accused of manslaughter said:

“Emotionally, it can be devastating for doctors when something goes wrong with a patient’s treatment, with the suggestion that you may have played a part in a patient's death. If it is then alleged that not only did you get it wrong, but you are a criminal in consequence, it can turn something which is deeply distressing into a nightmare.

“We hope that the government review will lead to some much needed help for doctors around this difficult situation. Doctors should be able to focus on doing their best for their patients when making difficult decisions without the increased pressure of thinking, ‘if I get this wrong, I could end up in prison’. In many cases system errors will have played a part. We need to fix the problem, not the blame.”


The MDU is a not-for-profit organisation wholly dedicated to our members’ interests. Our team is led and staffed by doctors with real-life experience of the pressures and challenges faced in practice.

We offer our members expert guidance, personal support and robust defence in addressing medico-legal issues, complaints and claims. Our customised services range from legal assistance to indemnity to appropriate CPD.


Dawn Boyall, Laura Baker or Thenuka Mahendrarasa in the MDU’s press office

t:     020 7202 1535/1504/1541
m:   07773 772 816/ 07903 192902
e:    dawn.boyall@themdu.com, laura.baker@themdu.com, thenuka.mahendrarasa@themdu.com
w:   themdu.com

More Articles by Medical Defence Union (MDU) ...

Disclaimer: Press releases published on this page are from key opinion formers who promote their organisation's activities by subscribing to a campaign site within politics.co.uk. politics.co.uk does not endorse, edit, or attempt to balance the opinions expressed on this page. The content of press releases are wholly the responsibility of the originating company or organisation.


Load in comments