Voice: Literacy experts ‘deeply concerned’ about government’s reading test for six year-olds

Friday, 28 October 2011 10:44 AM

Literacy experts ‘deeply concerned’ about government’s reading test for six year-olds

- Millions of pounds to be wasted as test will fail to accurately identify children’s needs

- High stakes approach will harm ‘enjoyment, comprehension and wider reading’

Many of the UK’s leading experts in the teaching of reading have written to Michael Gove, Secretary of State for Education, to strongly advise against proceeding with the pet policy of his Schools Minister, Nick Gibb.

Mr Gibb has been the force behind the creation of a 40-word test (half of them ‘nonsense words’) for Year 1 pupils (five and six year olds).

The test was piloted recently and its findings welcomed by the Minister – much to the puzzlement of experts who argue the results are certainly no cause for celebration.

Amazingly, the government intends to proceed despite the negative evidence gathered by its own pilot study and the test will be imposed on every Year 1 pupil in the UK next summer – potentially leading to a variety of hugely detrimental consequences, including:

- ‘teaching to the test’ resulting in a reduction of pupil enjoyment, comprehension and wider reading
- those most at need of reading support not being accurately identified by the test anyway
- increased workload for teachers (15.5 hours of administration on average, dismissed by Mr Gibb as just taking ‘a few minutes to carry out’)
- five and six year-olds pupils having less time with their class teacher
- the wasting of millions of pounds of taxpayers’ money

The text of the letter to Mr Gove can be found in full below.

For further comment, please contact UKLA at the University of Leicester, Leicester LE1 7RH

Tel: 0116 223 1664

Fax: 0116 223 1665

Email: admin@ukla.org

Voice: Senior Professional Officer (Education) Ian Toone:

Tel: 01332 372337 or iantoone@voicetheunion.org.uk

Press Office: pressoffice@voicetheunion.org.uk

Disclaimer: Press releases published on this page are from key opinion formers who promote their organisation's activities by subscribing to a campaign site within politics.co.uk. politics.co.uk does not endorse, edit, or attempt to balance the opinions expressed on this page. The content of press releases are wholly the responsibility of the originating company or organisation.

Related stories

Social mobility as bad as 1970s

Hughes insists reforms will show progress

Social mobility in the UK has not improved since the 1970s, despite ten years of a Labour government, a report by the Sutton Trust finds today.

Half a million 11-year-olds unable to read and write since 1997

Literacy appears unimproved from when Tony Blair entered Downing Street

The number of 11-year-olds leaving primary school unable to read or write has reached half a million since Labour came to power, according to figures released today.

Tories for central reading tests

The Conservatives are calling for external reading tests for seven-year-olds

Seven-year-olds would sit a national reading test under the Conservatives' new proposals to boost literacy.

Minister embraces reading overhaul

Politics.co.uk

A government-commissioned report today recommends an overhaul in the way children are taught to read in English schools.

MPs unimpressed by govt's 'dismal' literacy record

A dismal record?

The government's poor record on improving adult literacy and numeracy has been attacked by an influential group of MPs.

Galloway was victim of child abuse

Respect MP George Galloway revealed today that he was abused by a school caretaker at the age of 11.

Respect MP George Galloway revealed today that he was abused by a school caretaker at the age of 11.

Teachers told to forget red tape and embrace school trips

Balls wants more children to go on school trips

Schools and children secretary Ed Balls has said he wants pupils to take part in more school trips, as part of a bid to counter accusations of a "health and safety culture".

20,000 trainee teachers fail maths test

20,000 trainee teachers fail maths test

Around 20,000 trainee teachers have had to retake numeracy tests, according to figures released in a parliamentary answer.

Young Brits don't care about politics

Should the voting age be lowered to 16?

An overwhelming majority of young people in the UK don't trust politicians to make the right decisions for them, new research revealed.

Govt 'must do more' to raise basic skills

Key Stage 1 results flatline

The level of basic skills among seven-year-olds has not noticeably improved in the past year, but the government insists high standards have been maintained.

Press Releases

VoicetheUnion: School spending report could do better

Voice: the union for education professionals - School spending report could do better

JUAC calls for transparency as confusion and concern continues at Cwmcarn

VoicetheUnion: Educate, Empower, Enable

Voice calls on Nick Clegg to stand firm and block adult-child ratio changes

JUAC: Dear David Laws - open letter to David Laws MP on asbestos concerns

Voice concerned by new early years inspection regime

Voice welcomes early years research

Voice welcomes Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill

VoicetheUnion: Government’s childcare policies are see-saw

More Articles ...

Twitter

Join the conversation at #opinion_formers

Related Opinion Former Press Releases

NUT video: Christine Blower interview

NUT: Children left in tears and disengaged as literacy and numeracy tests are introduced

NUT Cymru says it has received alarming reports regarding the impact of the introduction of literacy and numeracy tests for all pupils from Year 2 – Year 9. Examples of students crying, reacting angrily and even threatening to no longer attend classes have been rife, especially amongst younger children.

NASUWT comments from April 2013 conference

NASUWT comments on professionalism of teaching, pay, pensions, and conditions, women's health and wellbeing in the teaching profession, and more.

Special event coverage

ESRC logo

Festival of Social Sciences: Celebrating the Social Sciences

Evidence-based policy should not be a radical concept. It needs to be celebrated.

ESRC logo

Festival of Social Sciences: 2 languages: 2 brains, 2 minds, 2 cultures?

As part of the ESRC Festival of Social Sciences, the Deafness Cognition And Language Research Centre (DCAL) hosted an event exploring the powerful benefits of bilingualism in spoken and sign languages, for hearing and deaf people alike - benefits that reach hearing and deaf people alike.

Opinion Former Events

MRSA Action UK Annual Memorial Event

Families will pay tribute and remember those lost to MRSA and healthcare associated infections at Westminster Abbey on Thursday 13th June 2013

BSIA: Information Destruction Exhibition & Conference 2013

Following the great success of the BSIA's Information Destruction Conference and Exhibition in May 2012, we are pleased to annouce that the event is returning again in June 2013. This one-day conference and exhibition is aimed at key decision makers in organisations that carry out the secure destruction of confidential material.