Scottish Government has “stronger mandate” to decide referendum question

Tuesday, 10 January 2012 9:34 AM

As controversy mounts over Westminster’s plans to set the terms of the mooted Scottish independence referendum the Electoral Reform Society Scotland has called on the government to accept that Holyrood has the “stronger mandate” to decide on the referendum question.

Willie Sullivan, Director of Electoral Reform Society Scotland said:

“Both sides clearly want to fight this referendum on terrain most favourable to them. The key test here can’t be about which side benefits most from setting the question or date - but on which body has the greatest democratic legitimacy to do so.

“The scales seem to tip in favour of the elected Government of Scotland and the Scottish Parliament. Westminster is a Parliament elected using an antiquated and unrepresentative system that does not adequately demonstrate the breadth of political views in Scotland.

“It would seem the Scottish parliament has the stronger mandate to debate and decide the referendum proposition and timing, with the Electoral Commission ruling on the final question and the operation of the referendum. We acknowledge there are legal issues to be addressed so its essential both Governments ensure any vote is not open to obvious legal challenge.

“The people of Scotland deserve clarity and to have their choice respected”

Acknowledging that any future settlement is a concern for the whole of the UK Willie Sullivan added:

“Once the Scottish people have expressed their views then Westminster can have her say” 

Disclaimer: Press releases published on this page are from key opinion formers who promote their organisation's activities by subscribing to a campaign site within politics.co.uk. politics.co.uk does not endorse, edit, or attempt to balance the opinions expressed on this page. The content of press releases are wholly the responsibility of the originating company or organisation.

Related stories

People's Pledge referendum diary: Week five

The People's Pledge wants a referendum on the EU.

How the electoral register stands in the way of direct democracy.

comments comments

Salmond pushes Scottish referendum vote

Alex Salmond wants a referendum on Scottish independence

Alex Salmond has said a referendum bill offering independence to the Scottish people will be enacted during the current Scottish parliament.

SNP and Tories round on Labour over Scottish referendum

Wendy Alexander's comments are causing trouble

The Scottish National party (SNP) and the Conservatives have both launched attacks on Gordon Brown for his handling of Wendy Alexander's calls for a referendum on Scottish independence.

Scotland may be handed referendum power

Do the people of Scotland want independence?

Whitehall officials could give Scotland the power to run its own independence referendum, it has been reported.

comments comments

Government failing to plan for Scottish independence security concerns

The committee said the government had not 'engaged' on security issues

The government has not adequately addressed concerns about the UK's national security strategy (NSS) ahead of the Scottish independence referendum, a parliamentary committee found today.

comments comments

'Get on with it', Scottish sec tells Salmond

'Get on with it', Scottish sec tells Salmond

An independence referendum could take place as soon as September 2013, Scottish secretary Michael Moore has said.

comments comments

Timeline: Scottish devolution

Politics.co.uk

The relationship between Scotland and the UK has changed almost beyond recognition since Scotland's first parliamentary election 1997. This is how it happened.

Comment: Cameron is trying to out-bluff Salmond over Scottish independence

Dr Matthew Ashton is a politics lecturer at Nottingham Trent University

The future of the UK is at stake. This is, without doubt, the biggest gamble of David Cameron's leadership.

comments comments

Fear of the unknown is motivating independence referendum manoeuvres

David Cameron and Alex Salmond are playing for high stakes

Another example of politicians using means other than their debating powers to get their way.

comments comments

Coalition plots to shape Scottish independence vote

Alex Salmond reviews his troops

Cabinet ministers could force the SNP to hold a Scottish independence referendum "sooner rather than later", prompting anger from Holyrood.

comments comments

Related Opinion Former Press Releases

ESRC scheme to provide evidence and analyse over Scottish Independence

With a referendum on Scottish Independence due to be held in 2014, the Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC) has appointed seven one year senior fellowships with overall funding of £1.3 million.

BHA: ‘Holy Redundant’: Bishops in the House of Lords campaign back by popular demand

The British Humanist Association has reactivated Holy Redundant campaign urging the public to email their MPs against continuing reserved places for bishops in the House of Lords following the Church of England’s 20th Nov 2012 vote to not to allow women to be bishops.

NASUWT condemns Westminister's arrogant pensions imposition in Scotland

Responding to reports that the Westminster Government is set to impose, without consultation, the direct link between the normal pension age and the state pension age on public sector workers in Scotland, despite the fact that responsibility for these matters is devolved to the Scottish Government, Chris Keates, General Secretary of the NASUWT, the fastest growing teachers' union in Scotland and the largest in the UK, said this:

Special event coverage

ESRC logo

Festival of Social Sciences: Celebrating the Social Sciences

Evidence-based policy should not be a radical concept. It needs to be celebrated.

ESRC logo

Festival of Social Sciences: 2 languages: 2 brains, 2 minds, 2 cultures?

As part of the ESRC Festival of Social Sciences, the Deafness Cognition And Language Research Centre (DCAL) hosted an event exploring the powerful benefits of bilingualism in spoken and sign languages, for hearing and deaf people alike - benefits that reach hearing and deaf people alike.

Opinion Former Events

BSIA: Information Destruction Exhibition & Conference 2013

Following the great success of the BSIA's Information Destruction Conference and Exhibition in May 2012, we are pleased to annouce that the event is returning again in June 2013. This one-day conference and exhibition is aimed at key decision makers in organisations that carry out the secure destruction of confidential material.