Opinion Former Briefing: Air rifle ban in Scotland

Monday, 23, Nov 2009 04:09

The right to ban air rifles in Scotland is expected to be handed to the Scottish government. Firearms legislation is usually handled in Westminster but in a recent review on devolution, Sir Kenneth Calman recommends its transfer to the government authorities in Holyrood.

The SNP has long argued that Scotland needs to ban air rifles after a number of high profile cases of shootings following guns falling into the wrong hands.

· Details of the deal are in the UK government's white paper responding to the Calman Commission that is to be published soon.

· UK legislation of airguns has been tightened so that the minimum age to own an airgun is now 18, mail orders have been banned and all retailers must be registered.

· It is unlikely that the new legislation will become law before the General Election due to be held next year.

The BASC comments:

"The last thing that either the police or the shooting and rural community needs is more complex legislation or licensing. What has proven effective over the last two years has been the police enforcing existing legislation and the Scottish Government, working with the shooting community, educating young people and their parents of their responsibilities with respect to airguns.

"In 1997 handguns and revolvers were effectively banned in Scotland, but last year the numbers of offences involving such firearms rose to a record of 130. Scottish Police Forces would be better deployed in addressing this serious matter rather than being forced into totally unnecessary licensing bureaucracy for airguns."

The Countryside Alliance comments:

"Countless laws are already in place to prevent criminals misusing airguns but the Scottish government wants to create yet more. We need fewer, better laws and proper enforcement of existing legislation - surely politicians have learned this lesson by now? Hundreds of thousands of law-abiding shooters are once again being penalised for the actions of a small number of repeat offenders. Education at a local level through the police, airgun clubs and schools is a more efficient way to reduce illegal behaviour rather than creating knee-jerk legislation which will not help victims of these idiots."

What do you think?

Name 

Location 

Email 

Comment 

Enter the text shown to the right
  • "Being a farmer I rely on my air-guns for shooting/controlling small vermin , its the safest way, of doing so,I have never been a danger to the public in over 30 years of owning air weapons. To me the answer is simple, anyone owning an air weapon, must either be a member of a Air Rifle?Pistol Shooting Club that is registered with proper insurance, or has written permission from a farmer/landowner and hold valid insurance, as far as I am concerned anyone else with Air weapons should not have them, I would be in favour of some sort of license being put in place, a move to ban air -guns is morally unfair to the decent law abiding citizens amongst us, and I feel Heart Sorry for those people who have lost family members or have been injured by a minority of air gun users."

    Richard McGlashan (Perthshire) Posted: 24/11/2009 12:59:14

  • "This isn't about safety primarily. This is about votes. The same as it was when handguns were banned in 1997. No lessons have been learned because it's far more important to be seen doing "something" rather than letting the opposition suggest "something else" that popular opinion likes the sound of. If governments were really concerned with safety they would stop under 21's from driving supercars, bring back the death penalty for murder, lock up anyone convicted of a crime of violence (and throw away the key) and stop interfering in the politics of distant countries under the pretext of making the world a safer place. The pistol ban didn't work, the airgun ban won't, but it will get the backing of the non shooting public - and you can be sure their voices will drown out the rest of ours. I sympathise with anyone shot with any gun, arrow or missile and utterly condemn the misuse of any apparatus that brings about the harm of man or animal but if the existing laws were upheld as they were meant to be then no new laws would be necessary. But then there aren't enough police officers, the ones we have got are too busy filling out crime reports and paperwork to be able to do useful policing, and finally when culprits of crime are brought to court they are regularly and often sent off with a telling off over and over again because there's no room in our jails and we can't afford to build new ones. Better hope they'll compensate us if we are forced to hand our airguns in. That's about the most you can hope for - especially when the tabloids start one of their campaigns. I feel particularly sorry for Scottish Airgunners as I remember them at the rallies in Trafalgar Square in 1997 (yes I rallied and lost). Scottish Airgunners deserve respect for coming down to London and rallying under their banner, and I call on all English airgunners to support them now in their time of need. Good luck guys (and girls)."

    Phil (England Luckily For Now) Posted: 25/11/2009 12:19:33

  • "Good grief, give more powers of any sort to the clowns at Holyrood? ban air rifles, very clever. So I can shoot rabbits with my 12 bore shotgun but not with my air rifle? Cricket bats are dangerous in the wrong hands, beaches are dangerous if you're really stupid or careless, so why not ban them too?"

    Lindsay Buchan (Edinburgh) Posted: 25/11/2009 18:02:20

  • "Oh gosh. This is another step of disarming the public - why? For power. For control. Look around, we have no power over the government. They have all the power. In every single case of Genocide in the history of mankind has involved some sort of gun control. Those who forget history are bound to repeat it."

    Callum Wood (Lincolnshire) Posted: 26/11/2009 18:19:30

  • "some people have been killed with cricket bats but we dont automotically ban cricket do we, people have been killed in a car accident we dont ban people from driving, i think to ban it would be unfair on MOST of the air rifle community 95% are law abiding citizens that are sensible enough to shoot and own a air rifle, just because a few people have got hold of one and done stupid acts doesnt mean that everyone should suffer i think the law should stay as it is there are already enough laws in place so whats the point in adding more. ?"

    Luke Cartwright (Chester) Posted: 27/11/2009 11:37:19

  • "As with all things , the minority shout and the world changes ! I have been a resposible airgun owner all my life , having served in the forces i was taught to a high standard to repect weapons , I hunt rabbits etc on farm land well away from the public ! Why not ban slingshots ? they can be far more dangerous ! Cricket bats, golf clubs It does not matter to the common thug which ! "

    James Craig (Larkhall) Posted: 19/12/2009 22:35:07

  • "im 15 ill be 16 this year. I have been shown how to fire wepons and handle them safly for years. I use my airgun on an estate. i hunt crows rabbits etc but where i shoot is miles from the public away up in the hills hunting myself and sometimes with my dad.i enjoy shooting and i have earned the respect of the farmer through years of beating and clay pigeon shooting and i dont think its fair that i and others should be punished for somthing we had no part in. its not the morons that your punishing they people dont care about airguns there gust thugs. if they ban air rifles the thugs will gust use knifes,baseball bats,hammers or even onto fire arms. its the law abeiding sittisons that they are punishing =[ i love my gun my parends and i worked hard for the money to buy it and its my pride and joy i would hate it to have to give it up..."

    Adam wilson (lanark shire) Posted: 14/01/2010 21:13:55

  • ""after a number of high profile cases of shootings following guns falling into the wrong hands" Well...how many times has a car fell into the wrong hands...a drunk, an underage reckless teen! Do we ban anything of potential harm? Kitchen knives? People depend on air guns as a method of pest control. It's also a good outdoor sport. 99% of owners are respectable members of the public. 1% are idiots. But we will always have idiots....idiots in cars...idiots with blunt objects...idiots! "Lets ban sex to stop acts of rape. Therefore stopping child birth and ridding the world of pheadophiles and rapists!" How far do you go?"

    Anonymous (Anon) Posted: 28/01/2010 00:08:34

  • "i have owned shotguns and high powered rifles but the best of all are my airguns, i come from a family of shooters and fishermen and i had my first airgun when i was 5 years old a little gat gun by the age of 12 i was shooting shotguns, aged 18 i joined the army and took all my skills and honed them in there for 8 years as a sniper.i now have three sons who all shoot airguns and they respect guns and what they can do, i respect guns what i dont respect are the idiots behind them guns dont go around killing people idiots do. i gave up my shotgun licence and my fac years ago and now i use only my airguns.i have paid over £3,000 on my airguns,will i be paid to hand them in ??? i dont think so, we will be expected to just be good citizens and hand them over because they can kill or maime.sorry first minister but you can shove it right where the sun dont shine,i'll be the first to see the inside of a cell cause you aint getting mine,great 50 years old and i want to start breaking the law.as for the people who do abuse airguns i hope your in the cell with me, you wont get out safely."

    airgunner (Lanarkshire) Posted: 03/02/2010 23:53:19

  • "Banning air rifles wont stop people geting guns. Take a look at those thugs with ak47's and glock 18c's down in london. Did banning pistols and automatics stop them?"

    James (Scotland, Fife, Buckhaven) Posted: 06/04/2010 11:34:15


Election Video Manifestos

politics.co.uk's Opinion Formers present their manifesto "wish lists" to the next generation of MPs and ministers ahead of the General Election in 2010.


Opinion Former Manifestos

Countryside Alliance Rural Manifesto

This manifesto flags up several key issues which truly matter to individuals and groups within rural communities. These are issues that genuinely affect peoples' lives in the countryside right now. They provoke passion, idealism, energy, anger and frustration. They put people on the street, inspire them to participate and ultimately drive them to vote in large numbers.


Opinion Former Press Releases

RSPCA Treats Floods As National Emergency- Teams to Help to People, Pets and Livestock

The RSPCA is deploying at least 60 specially-trained staff across Cumbria to offer rescue assistance to both people and their animals.

FSB Opens Emergency fund for Flooded Businesses

The Federation of Small Businesses (FSB) has opened its £500,000 Disaster Recovery Fund for its members in Scotland, Lancashire and Cumbria and the North East of England, which have been adversely affected by recent heavy rain and flooding.

Overhaul of flood management must now be given priority says the ABI

Today's publication of the Flood and Water Management Bill must signal the start of an overhaul in how the UK manages the rising flood risk, says the ABI.

BASC: 'Wine and Game' - new guide goes online

A new guide, which will help food lovers choose the perfect wine to drink with their game dinners, has been launched this week.

BASC continues the fight for shooters' rights on coastal access

The British Association for Shooting and Conservation (BASC) will ensure that the interests of shooters are fully considered in the final drafting of secondary legislation and guidance stemming from the enactment of the Marine and Coastal Access Bill.

Countryside Alliance - Post Office consultations "undermined communities"

The Countryside Alliance has agreed with Public Accounts Committee's report into the 2007 Post Office closures which has branded the Government's consultations "window dressing".

Countryside Alliance: Last hunting season under the ban?

Hunts across the country are holding opening meets this Saturday at the start of what could be the last season under the Hunting Act. A new survey* from the Countryside Alliance has revealed that the campaign for repeal is receiving record levels of support.

BASC: Young shots learn about deer management in the New Forest

Young shots in the south east have been learning about deer management in the New Forest from its keepers this week.

Countryside Alliance: start of the season, Saturday 31st October

At the start of what could be the last season before the Hunting Act is repealed, representatives from the Countryside Alliance will be in attendance to greet media at the following meets this Saturday, 31st October from 10.30am.

RSPCA Gets Rose the cow moo-ving

The RSPCA teamed up with firefighters to rescue a cow which was stuck in a stream near Mill Lane in Rickinghall, Suffolk.