BHA: Mentally competent adults should be able to choose to end their lives

Thursday, 16 August 2012 3:04 PM

Tony Nicklinson has lost his High Court case to allow doctors to end his life without risk of prosecution.  Mr Nicklinson, who is 58, suffered a catastrophic stroke in 2005 which left him with locked-in syndrome, which means that he is paralysed from the neck down. 

He communicates by blinking, and has described his life since the stroke as a ‘living nightmare’.  He says that he is ‘devastated’ by the court’s decision, and that ‘I am saddened that the law wants to condemn me to a life of increasing indignity and misery.’  Mr Nicklinson also said that he would appeal against the decision.  Another man, known as Martin, who is 47 and suffering from locked in syndrome, also lost his case to end his life with help from doctors.

The British Humanist Association (BHA) is disappointed at this decision.

Andrew Copson BHA Chief Executive, commented ‘We are deeply disappointed by this news for Tony. We fully supported the legal case to establish the right to have a doctor lawfully end his life.

‘Mentally competent adults should be able to make decisions about their lives, as long as they do not result in harm to others.  In cases where a patient is suffering incurably, is permanently incapacitated, and has made a clear and informed decision to end their life but is unable to do so independently, the law should allow a doctor to intervene.  We also believe that there is an urgent need for Parliament to legislate on the matter, and to introduce a law which legalises assisted dying while also imposing safeguards to protect the vulnerable.

‘We will continue to support Tony as he appeals this decision and will also continue to call for an ethical and humane law on assisted dying that would protect the vulnerable, but also allow mentally competent adults the right to die with dignity in a time and manner of their own choosing.’

Notes

For further comment or information contact Pavan Dhaliwal, Head of Public Affairs at pavan@humanism.org.uk or on 0773 843 5059.

The British Humanist Association is the national charity working on behalf of ethically concerned, non-religious people in the UK. It is the largest organisation in the UK campaigning for an end to religious privilege and to discrimination based on religion or belief, and for a secular state

Disclaimer: Press releases published on this page are from key opinion formers who promote their organisation's activities by subscribing to a campaign site within politics.co.uk. politics.co.uk does not endorse, edit, or attempt to balance the opinions expressed on this page. The content of press releases are wholly the responsibility of the originating company or organisation.

Related stories

A question of murder: Right-to-die case gets green light

Ministers argue only parliament can decide on right-to-die issues

A paralysed man's bid to end his life lawfully in the UK will have a full hearing in court, Mr Justice Charles has ruled.

comments comments

Locked-in syndrome sufferer dies days after losing euthanasia case

Tony Nicklinson's death comes days after losing his right-to-die case

Tony Nicklinson, the man who lost his right-to-die court bid last week, has passed away.

comments comments

Comment: We support the right to die - but not for Paul Lamb

Sarah Wootton: 'Dignity in Dying's desired law change is based on mental competence and terminal illness. While Paul Lamb is mentally competent, he is not terminally ill.'

Paul Lamb is campaigning for the right to end his life legally. While it is clear he is suffering, Dignity in Dying does not support his case.

comments comments

Analysis: Britain's options for legalising euthanasia

Louise Bazalgette is a Senior Researcher at Demos

MPs will have to tread carefully if they decide to make assisted dying legal in Britain.

comments comments

Judge rejects 'minimally conscious' right to die case

Mr Justice Baker said the "unique" case raised "very important issues of principle".

A 'minimally conscious' brain-damaged woman should not be allowed to die, a high court judge has ruled.

comments comments

Comment: How to defeat the argument for capital punishment in 30 seconds

'Demands for the death penalty say considerable more about the personality of people who make them than they do about criminal justice.'

With campaigners trying to get capital punishment debated on the floor of the Commons, we should remind ourselves how staggeringly easy it is to dismantle their argument.

comments comments

The Political Week Online: A bad week for liberty

A sad week for anyone who loves liberty

The Royal Charter, Lucy Meadows, and a vote on workfare: this has not been a happy week for anyone who values personal freedom.

comments comments

Comment: Legislation is not the answer for assisted suicide

Politics.co.uk

You can't legislate for assisted suicide or euthanasia satisfactorily enough for murder not to go unpunished.

PM wades into euthanasia TV debate

A still from the Syy Real Lives programme

Gordon Brown has waded into the debate on tonight's programme showing a man dying in an assisted suicide clinic in Switzerland.

'Motive' is new focus for assisted dying prosecutors

Assisted dying: New guidelines published today

The "motivation of the suspect" has been made the main focus for prosecutors when they assess assisted dying cases, but the director of public prosecutions has denied relaxing rules on euthanasia.

Press Releases

BHA: Strong public support for legal humanist marriages as Lords prepare to debate

BHA: MPs vote against adding PSHE to the national curriculum

BHA: Can science solve every mystery?

BHA: Religious selection in school admissions is unfair, unpopular, unnecessary and a global outlier

BHA backs launch of Fair Admissions Campaign

Northern Ireland’s Catholic schools call for end to faith-based school employment laws

European Court of Human Rights refuses to hear appeals in three ‘Christian persecution’ cases

BHA welcomes new findings in support of compulsory sex and relationships education

Government approves 25 new religious Free Schools

Legal recognition of humanist marriages blocked in Commons

More Articles ...

Twitter

Join the conversation at #opinion_formers

Related Opinion Former Press Releases

BHA: Court of Appeal allows ‘L’ to proceed with Tony Nicklinson Claim

The Court of Appeal has decided that a man called ‘L’ can be joined to the legal case of the late Tony Nicklinson’s claim to establish the right to a doctor assisted death. Jane Nicklinson has pursued the claim in her own right under Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights as well as the Administratix of the Estate of Tony Nicklinson. The British Humanist Association (BHA), which has intervened in the claims, very much welcomes this news.

BHA supports Tony Nicklinson’s legal case for a new approach on assisted dying

Tony Nicklinson, a paralysed man who is campaigning for a doctor to be allowed to lawfully end his life, is having his case heard at the High Court this week. As a result of a stroke in 2005, he suffers from ‘locked-in syndrome’, which means that he is of sound mind, but is paralysed from the neck down and is unable to speak. Mr Nicklinson wants the judges presiding over his case to rule that, if he makes the informed decision to end his life, a doctor will be immune from prosecution if they help him to do so. The British Humanist Association (BHA) supports Mr Nicklinson’s legal case, and in addition to this, would also like to see legislation in Parliament to legalise assisted dying.

BHA: Nicklinson, Lamb and ‘Martin’ assisted dying hearings at Court of Appeal begin

Hearings begin at the Court of Appeal today of the cases of: Paul Lamb, immobilised after a road accident and seeking the right to an assisted death; Jane Nicklinson, the widow of Tony Nicklinson, who also sought an assisted death; and a claimant known as ‘Martin’ in the same position. The British Humanist Association (BHA) is also a party to the case, as an intervener on the side of assisted dying.

Special event coverage

ESRC logo

Festival of Social Sciences: Celebrating the Social Sciences

Evidence-based policy should not be a radical concept. It needs to be celebrated.

ESRC logo

Festival of Social Sciences: 2 languages: 2 brains, 2 minds, 2 cultures?

As part of the ESRC Festival of Social Sciences, the Deafness Cognition And Language Research Centre (DCAL) hosted an event exploring the powerful benefits of bilingualism in spoken and sign languages, for hearing and deaf people alike - benefits that reach hearing and deaf people alike.

Opinion Former Events

Bpas event: Working Together for Women

Join bpas for an informal networking event which will provide an opportunity to talk to others looking to work together to effect policy changes to improve women’s lives and hear from speakers who are doing just that.