BHA: Committee recommends retaining bishops in a reformed House of Lords

Monday, 23 April 2012 10:56 AM

The Government’s proposals to maintain and effectively strengthen the influence of the Church of England in Parliament have today received support from the Joint Committee on the Draft House of Lords Reform Bill, although only be majority and not by consensus. The British Humanist Association (BHA), which gave evidence to the Committee, has expressed its dismay at the report and said again that, ‘Reserved places for Bishops are unfair, unjustified, unpopular, and should go.’

The Government’s Draft House of Lords Reform Bill will lead to an increase in the proportion of ‘Lord Spiritual’ from 3% of appointed peers, to anything between 12% and 17% of appointed peers, depending on the eventual size of a reformed chamber. If the Government’s proposals were enacted, Anglican Bishops would likely outnumber SNP, Plaid Cymru, DUP, SDLP, Sinn Fein and Green Peers combined.[1]

Commenting on the Joint Committee’s report, BHA Chief Executive Andrew Copson said: ‘The report of the Committee published today is at odds with the reasoned evidence submitted to it and presents no good arguments whether in principle or otherwise for the retention of Bishops.

‘More hopeful is the fact that the Committee was divided on the issue and supported retaining Bishops by a majority not by a consensus. We hope that the voices of those who want a fairer chamber and better represent the view of the wider public - 74% of whom (including 70% of Christians) believe it is wrong that Church of England Bishops are given automatic places – will prevail as the debate on Lords reform moves forward.’

The BHA will continue its campaign for equitable Lords Reform and is urging the Government to reconsider and amend the Draft Reform Bill.


[1] Using the percentage of votes cast for each party at the 2012 General election, and assuming Proportional Representation.

For further comment or information contact BHA Chief Executive Andrew Copson on 07534 248596 or at andrew@humanism.org.uk

Disclaimer: Press releases published on this page are from key opinion formers who promote their organisation's activities by subscribing to a campaign site within politics.co.uk. politics.co.uk does not endorse, edit, or attempt to balance the opinions expressed on this page. The content of press releases are wholly the responsibility of the originating company or organisation.

Related stories

Deep divisions reveal rocky road ahead for Lords reform

Lords reform hasn't been achieved for over 100 years - and counting

Fundamental divisions among MPs and peers over proposed elections for the Lords are signalling a tough road ahead for the coalition's reforms.

comments comments

Lords reform: Both sides gather strength for the struggle to come

"A bill will be brought forward to reform the composition of the House of Lords"

As the coalition devises its strategy behind closed doors, the enemies of Lords reform are sitting and waiting. A big, big fight is coming up over the horizon fast.

comments comments

Lords rebels 'not fit to be MPs'

The party said the House of Lords is an '18th century sham'

Those who voted against Lords reform are "not fit to be MPs", the Green party said in a scathing statement today.

comments comments

Bishops could be banned from House of Lords

House of Lords reform: towards disestablishment?

Bishops could be banned from the House of Lords, under new reform plans being considered by Gordon Brown.

Bishops in the Lords survive, but their privileges could be on the line

No need to look over their shoulder - on the big issues, at least

The bishops may be set to survive the coalition's Lords reforms, but important questions remain to be resolved about their role in the Lords.

comments comments

Nick Clegg House of Lords statement in full

Clegg announces the end of House of Lords reform and a whipping operation against the boundary review

Read Nick Clegg's explosive speech announcing the end of Lords reform and a boundary change rebellion in full.

comments comments

Nick Clegg House of Lords reform speech in full

Nick Clegg on House of Lords reform.

Read Nick Clegg's statement to the Commons kicking off the debate on House of Lords reform in full on politics.co.uk.

comments comments

Tory grumblers told to fall in line over Lords reform

Minister ready to use Parliament Act to push through Lords reform

Lords reform was in manifesto, Mark Harper points out

comments comments

Lords reform's death by a thousand cuts

Does a 21st century Britain need a reformed Lords

It was a grisly, tortuous demise meted out on criminal miscreants in late Qing dynasty China. In 21st century Britain, the death by a thousand cuts is reserved for another purpose: polishing off the coalition's Lords reforms.

comments comments

Lords reform debate day one as-it-happened

The Lords tower looms over Westminster, as a massive constitutional struggle gets underway in earnest

Review our live blog and rolling analysis as MPs debated the Lords reform bill ahead of Tuesday evening's crunch vote.

comments comments

Press Releases

BHA: Strong public support for legal humanist marriages as Lords prepare to debate

BHA: MPs vote against adding PSHE to the national curriculum

BHA: Can science solve every mystery?

BHA: Religious selection in school admissions is unfair, unpopular, unnecessary and a global outlier

BHA backs launch of Fair Admissions Campaign

Northern Ireland’s Catholic schools call for end to faith-based school employment laws

European Court of Human Rights refuses to hear appeals in three ‘Christian persecution’ cases

BHA welcomes new findings in support of compulsory sex and relationships education

Government approves 25 new religious Free Schools

Legal recognition of humanist marriages blocked in Commons

More Articles ...

Twitter

Join the conversation at #opinion_formers

Related Opinion Former Press Releases

BHA: ‘Holy Redundant’: Bishops in the House of Lords campaign back by popular demand

The British Humanist Association has reactivated Holy Redundant campaign urging the public to email their MPs against continuing reserved places for bishops in the House of Lords following the Church of England’s 20th Nov 2012 vote to not to allow women to be bishops.

MPs urged by BHA to call for removal of Bishops as part of House of Lords reform

Ahead of the first full parliamentary debate, MPs have been urged to speak against the Government’s proposals to retain Church of England bishops in a reformed House of Lords, with the British Humanist Association (BHA) calling the proposals ‘unjust, unpopular and unfair’.

BHA: Government abandons House of Lords reform

Liberal Democrat leader Nick Clegg announced today that the government will abandon its plans for reform of the House of Lords. The British Humanist Association (BHA) is disappointed at this decision, because we hoped that Lords Reform would provide an opportunity for removing the right of Bishops to reserved seats in Parliament. However... read more.

Special event coverage

ESRC logo

Festival of Social Sciences: Celebrating the Social Sciences

Evidence-based policy should not be a radical concept. It needs to be celebrated.

ESRC logo

Festival of Social Sciences: 2 languages: 2 brains, 2 minds, 2 cultures?

As part of the ESRC Festival of Social Sciences, the Deafness Cognition And Language Research Centre (DCAL) hosted an event exploring the powerful benefits of bilingualism in spoken and sign languages, for hearing and deaf people alike - benefits that reach hearing and deaf people alike.

Opinion Former Events

Bpas event: Working Together for Women

Join bpas for an informal networking event which will provide an opportunity to talk to others looking to work together to effect policy changes to improve women’s lives and hear from speakers who are doing just that.