PAT comments on the proposed educational opportunity bill

PAT logo for press releases

Thursday, 01, Nov 2007 12:00

PAT General Secretary Philip Parkin said: “Raising the school leaving age is a potential minefield that could be disastrous. We could end up with married, voting parents being disciplined or criminalised for not attending school or college.

“It is hardly surprising that some disenchanted young people do not want to set themselves up to be further alienated by compulsory 16 to 18 education or business-led training designed for purely economic reasons to fill a skills gap. To make them conscripts is likely to reinforce failure, leading to even greater disaffection.

”Enforcement could lead to mass truancy, disruption to other learners and staff, maybe even needless criminalisation if ‘enforcement measures’ are imposed. Would young people or their parents be punished for non-attendance?

”Schools and colleges will be forced to accept a host of unwilling students who will poison the atmosphere for those willing to learn. Forcing an education on teenagers will create even more youngsters with a grudge against society.

“There is not a strong case for introducing compulsory participation in education or training to 18. There is a strong case for providing high quality provision for all when they are ready to learn. In the spirit of lifelong learning, the exciting opportunities in education and training should be the carrot and not the stick to encourage participation.

”We see far too many young people switched off from learning as a result of an overbearing testing regime. We should increase the number of young people in education or training, but without conscription. We should provide appropriate opportunities but allow young adults some choice between work and/or education and training.

”If we can get it right from the beginning of a child’s life, through good parenting, universal adequate funding in the early years, appropriate high quality learning and care opportunities, and joined-up services, we could avoid so many children failing or being at risk of failing later. Then, with the right curriculum or training programme on offer, taught in the right way, in the right surroundings, voluntary uptake beyond 16 is likely to increase.”

Opinion Former Comment

Shelter responds to the Queen's speech We welcome the renewed commitment to ending child poverty by 2020.
BASC statement on Marine Bill BASC will help shooting interests address concerns in the new Marine Bill which has been announced in the Queen’s Speech.
SCP response to Queen's speech: What about pensioner poverty The Senior Citizens Party (www.seniorcitizensparty.org.uk) warmly welcomes the Government's commitment to abolishing Child Poverty by 2020, but is appalled that there is no mention whatsoever in the Queen's Speech about Pensioner Poverty.
MRSA Action UK: Is the NHS Constitution, more broken pledges, or a real Constitution for the rights of patients? At the State opening of Parliament the Government unveiled the proposal for a bill to be brought forward to strengthen the National Health Service.
Countryside Alliance: Wrong route to coastal access The new Marine Bill, announced in today’s Queen’s Speech, takes the wrong route to increasing access to coastal areas by proposing ‘access corridors’ rather than footpaths, according to the Countryside Alliance.
Crisis warns that tough welfare reform not the answer for vulnerable people Crisis, the national charity for single homeless people, whilst broadly welcoming the welfare reform plans outlined in the Queen’s speech today, warns that a tough approach could leave vulnerable people facing hardship.
Chamber of Shipping: One Voice comment on the Marine and Coastal Access Bill The UK maritime industry fully supports the Marine and Coastal Access Bill, but stresses the need for proper consideration of the interests of UK shipping and the wider commercial maritime sector” said Richard Everitt, chairman of One Voice.
Investment in skills needed to tackle recession, says UCU in response to Queen’s speech The University and College Union (UCU) said today (Wednesday) that further education should be at the heart of tackling the recession as people seek to refresh their skills as they seek employment.
NHF says banking reform must ensure lenders don't unreasonably change loan conditions to housing associations The National Housing Federation today said the banking reforms, to be implemented in the new Parliamentary session, must stop lenders from unreasonably changing the terms and conditions of loans – an issue which is threatening the delivery of new social housing across the country.
CIOB hopes Queen's speech will lead to improved payment practices in the construction industry The Chartered Institute of Building (CIOB) welcomes the announcement in today’s Queen’s Speech of the Government’s intention to improve the operation of construction contracts.
Royal College of Physicians: Reaction to the Queen's speech Although the Government’s commitment to improve public health is welcome, it is disappointing that how they intend to achieve it was not set out more clearly.
PCS responds to Queen's speech The Public and Commercial Services Union (PCS) warned that the welfare reform plans announced in today’s Queen’s Speech are the wrong proposals at the wrong time which will penalise some of the most disadvantaged in society.
CEP comment on Queen's speech 2008 The CEP comment on the Queen's speech has to be on the Equality Bill which is intended to 'simplify and harmonise discrimination law'.
Federation of Small Businesses response to the Queen’s Speech 2008 The Federation of Small Businesses (FSB) welcomed the announcement in today’s Queen’s Speech to crack down on the banks as part of a series of major reforms to the financial sector.
IFAW: Government urged to use new Marine Bill to protect marine mammals from man-made ocean noise pollution The International Fund for Animal Welfare (IFAW) welcomed the announcement of the Marine Bill in the Queen’s Speech today as an important step to protect UK marine life – but urged the Government to use the Bill to tackle the growing threat from man-made underwater noise pollution.
British Humanist Association welcomes Equality Bill, with some caution against unintended consequences The British Humanist Association (BHA) has welcomed the announcement of the Equality Bill in today’s Queen’s Speech.
RCP: The Queen's Speech: Welfare reforms 'must support people with mental health problems', say four leading organisations Four leading mental health organisations have today united in calling on the Government to ensure that any welfare reform measures in the Queen's Speech (1) give the best possible support for people with mental health problems to find and keep jobs.
ABI: Queen's speech 2008 - preparing for the challenges of the future Tomorrow’s Queen’s Speech 2008 is expected to contain several pieces of legislation of importance to the insurance industry and its customers, based on the draft legislative programme announced in May.