politics.co.uk Logo

News

Field slams Labour record

Tuesday, 03 Jun 2008 00:01
Frank Field speaks out against govt
Labour has failed its core voters on immigration and public services, leading rebel Frank Field will say later today.

The former welfare minister and leader of the backbench rebels responsible for Gordon Brown's humiliating 10p income tax U-turn will make the claim in a lecture at the University of Hertfordshire, where he is chancellor.

Mr Field believes Labour is in the same position as the doomed Liberal party, which went into terminal decline after the first world war.

"Labour has failed to represent its core vote on two issues which these voters put towards the top of their agenda," he will say.

"It has allowed uncontrolled immigration with its impact not just on earnings but more generally on housing, schools and other public services, to the disadvantage of working class English voters, both white and black."

He will warn the British National party (BNP) could prove attractive to many core Labour voters, both on immigration and on Labour's failure to address unresolved devolution issues.

Mr Field wants the prime minister to lead efforts to give greater independence to England, which many fear is underrepresented at parliament. Issues affecting it are voted on by Scottish and Welsh MPs, but English MPs do not have a say over affairs in devolved areas.

"Just as it was conventional wisdom that the Tories were best placed to enact decolonisation so, similarly, will a Scottish prime minister be best placed to resolve the English question," Mr Field will say.

"By initiating a debate, and admitting that at this stage no one quite knows where the process will lead, Gordon Brown would both set some of the parameters as well as the speed of the debate."

Ultimately a failure to address the issue could lead to electoral disaster, Mr Field adds.

He says the English question is "a real threat which could all too easily have a catastrophic impact on the party’s ability to challenge for power in England".


Comment on this story... 

Name 

Town/Country 

Your email 

Your comment 

Enter the text shown to the right

Your views 

  • When will English Labour wake up and smell the haggis? Before the party is wiped out forever in England, by pursuing Scottish socialist policies, the English MPs must break away and form an English Labour Party. One that converts to English socialism, not Scottish socialism. The differences are that the English believe help is required where it is deserved. Not that riding the benefits wagon is a life-style choice and everything should be provided free to everyone. That's Scottish socialism and it's not what we want in England. The Labour Party in England is dying. But it is not too late to form an English Labour Party and send the Scottish socialists packing. Helen Wright, Yorkshire
  • Frank is right - as usual. The trouble is that Gordon Brown will not allow the English to rule themselves. Between them Tony Blair and Gordon Brown will destroy the Union. We need serious discussions between all the political parties on converting the multi-nation Union into a multi-nation federation. Otherwise each of the nations will go their own way - sooner rather than later. Ian Campbell, West Horsley

Speakers' Corner 

Related news