Home

Govt must stop jailing women, charities say

Most women recieve short sentencesMost women recieve short sentences

Wednesday, 18, Jun 2008 12:01

The government has come under unprecedented pressure to stop jailing non-violent women criminals from a broad coalition of charities.

It is the first time the charitable foundations, which include the Diana Memorial Fund, have lobbied the government in this way.

Pushed by politics.co.uk on whether the plans would make men less equal than women in the eyes of the criminal justice system, Teresa Elwes of the Bromley Trust responded: "We are looking at equality at the outcome level.

"Prisons were designed for men. Women's prisons use centres which were designed for men. For example, some women's prisons didn’t have women's toilets.

"They had to start thinking in a different way but they never did really," she continued.

"Women's needs have never been very influential in the design or concept of prisons. We're looking at a completely different set up for the needs of women, like small residential prisons where women can still see their children."

Frances Crook, director of the Howard League for Penal Reform, agrees.

"Women in custody remain locked into an inhumane system with heavy-handed levels of punishment, poorly trained staff, inadequate healthcare and sparse opportunities for rehabilitation and family contact," she told politics.co.uk

"Meanwhile, the female prison population continues to rise, last week reaching a record high of 4,505, and 2007 saw the number of female prisoners committing suicide leaping by 167% on the previous year."

The groups are calling on justice secretary Jack Straw to carry through on the reforms recommended in the government sponsored review into vulnerable women in the criminal justice system by Baroness Corston.

They want to see incarceration greatly decreased as a form of sentencing and the introduction of alternatives, such as local supervision and support centres.

They say only five per cent of children remain in the family home when their mother is imprisoned, and that this often creates a new generation of criminal activity. For the woman, separation from their children greatly increases the likelihood of suicide and self-harm.

More women are sent to prison for theft and handling goods than any other offence with 63 per cent receiving less than six months. One in three women in prison has been sexually abused and 50 per cent suffered domestic violence

The charitable trusts lobbying the government include Antigone, the Bromley Trust, the Nationwide Foundation the Diana Memorial Fund and the Westminster Trust.

Sarah Campbell, of women's rights group The Fawcett Society, commented: "Prison for women simply isn't working.

"What is needed now is a real financial investment in community provision for women who offend. It is time for the Government must put its money where its mouth is by investing in community sentences for women instead of prisons."

A Ministry of Justice spokesperson said: "The government aims to reduce the reliance on prison for low risk female offenders by focusing on improving provision and interventions in the community.

"However where a custodial sentence is appropriate we are ensuring the needs of women are understood and prioritised."


What do you think ?

Name 

Town/Country 

Your email 

Your comment 

Enter the text shown to the right

Your Views...

Alex Watson, Edinburgh: GET A LIFE YOU POLITICAL CORRECT FOOLS.So a woman who has children should get it easier than a man who has children for the same crime. What are you PC fools going to come up with NEXT. The old saying should stand for women and men IF YOU CANT DO THE TIME DON'T DO THE CRIME.All you want to do is pamper prisoners colour TVs the right to sue for anything they don't like we are the only country in the EU that goes by the book just look at France,Holland Germany etc. You PC fools are the ones who are going by the rules in the EU constitution. OPEN YOUR EYES.

I was told a few years ago that 'discrimination is to be identified by the victim'. It is up to a victim to decide what is or is not offensive or bigotted. As a man I can honestly say that no one thing has ever offended me as much as these proposals. Having campaigned about this issue now since as far back as 2001, when I first heard it suggested, my view is the same: it is persecution. The Corston Report only revealed half of the story. Simply look at the two studies carried out by The Prison Reform Trust and Mind between 2002 and 2005 and you will see that the findings were more or less the same. 72% of male prisoners and 70% of female prisoners have two or more mental health problems, including conditions like schizophrenia. Very shocking figures. Men are 5 times more likely to committ suicide in prison than not in prison, young men aged 15-17 are 18 times more likely to committ suicide in prison than not in prison. Why do they not care about equally vulnerable prisoners? As the comment below states why do they not care about fathers who miss their children? At the very least a report into the vulnerability of male prisoners is needed, since the Corston Report looked only into the vulnerability of female prisoners. Is this persecution? A simple test. A man who has schizophrenia, or another condition that could cause him to self-harm or committ suicide would receive no help while a woman who does not have this condition would. It is blatant persecution. But I'm sure that when it was allowable for landlords in the UK to put up signs like "No Blacks, No Dogs, No Irish" there was some 'reason'. Or to send men to prison just because they were gay. In all cases, just ask the victim and you will understand that no persecution is justified. Richard, West Yorkshire

Well the double standard is working as per the norm I see. How anyone can say western women are oppressed in any way shape or form with a straight face is one heck of a liar. Both sexes are meant to be treated equal, not All Sexes Are Equal But Some Are More Equal Than Others rubbish we have now. Christopher Williams, England

This is typical feminist hypocrisy. When women kill their children, it's because they're "mentally ill, driven to it, can't cope, etc." but when men kill their children it's because "men are evil". When women break the law, they're victims - and alleged to be victims of domestic violence by ... some evil man, no doubt. When men break the law, it's because "men are evil" and deserve to be raped in prison, given inadequate healthcare, etc. but it's ok - they're only men, so who cares, right? Certainly those claiming to be for 'equality' do NOT care one little bit, as demonstrated by this sexist demand for, yet again, preferencial treatment of women. Does it not occur to the women's groups that men too miss their children, and statistics also confirm that children from fatherless homes also are more prone to enter a life of crime, violence, drugs and so forth... so using the children as pawns (gee, how unusual) to garner pity for women is a clear demonstration of the underhanded tactics of feminism. Karl Mathews, Worcs

What a bunch of sexist reteric. This world has gone potty with sexism. What gives. I thought (NOT) that feminism was about equality. Yeh right. Steve Mac, Sydney

Can you imagine the uproar if the headline had been 'Stop jailing men'. I forgot sexism only works one way!! If anyone, male or female, breaks the law they should face the consequences. Lets face it, you don't go to prison for a first offence shoplifting. Time to stop the bleeding heart liberal do-gooders, responsible for the decline in discipline and social failures in our society. Alastair, Linlithgow


New jobs channel

The new look politics.co.uk now includes a jobs channel, where you can search for jobs and sign up for our jobs bulletin.

Newsletter

Sign up to politics.co.uk’s daily newsletter and you’ll never miss a key political story again

Opinion Formers

BSIA - The British Security Industry Association

The British Security Industry Association is the principal trade association for professional security companies in the UK. We represent over 550 security companies.

Public Affairs Jobs

Check out politics.co.uk's new jobs section, for government, public sector and public affairs roles.

politics.co.uk brings you a new monthly roundup of public affairs, government and local government appointments.

Current Vacancies:

Related News

Radical preacher Qatada 'to be bailed in 24 hours'

Abu Qatada, the radical Islamic preacher convicted of terrorist offences in Jordan, is to be released on bail in the UK within the next 24 hours.

Radical Islamic preacher dubbed Osama Bin Laden's right-hand man in Europe to be bailed within 24 hours

Latest Headlines

Concern over adult retraining courses

Those who have lost their jobs because of the recession and looking to reskill are facing a decline in the number of available courses because of the government's policies, it has been claimed.

Adult learning faces funding shortfall

Legislation

Counterterrorism bill

The bill is part of wide reaching measures to improve the detection and policing of terrorism. It will bring in post-charge questioning and could introduce the use of intercept evidence. It backs increasing the period for detention without trial to 56 days.

Immigration detention centres

What are immigration detention centres? Immigration detention centres are holding centres for foreign nationals waiting decisions on their asylum claims or waiting deportation following a failed application.