Smith's anti-porn policies highlighted

Jacqui Smith, home secretaryJacqui Smith, home secretary

Reddit

Stumble

 

Opinion Formers

Electoral Reform Society

The Electoral Reform Society is a voluntary organisation that campaigns for a better democracy, particularly through changes to our electoral system.

Find more Opinion Formers in this category:

 

Related News

Government blocks equality in the monarchy

Far-reaching plans to rid the monarchy of male-preference and anti-Catholicism have been blocked by the government.

Proposed bill "not appropriate vehicle" for changes
 

Related Analysis

Mohamed torture investigation: Reactions

All the reactions on the investigation into allegations of British complicity in torture, from Binyam Mohamed himself to Gordon Brown.

Binyam Mohamed was kept in Guantanamo Bay for years

Monday, 30, Mar 2009 05:39

By Laura Miller

Jacqui Smith's work pushing through anti-porn laws has been highlighted now she is embroiled in a scandal involving adult movies.

Ben Westwood, who campaigned against the introduction of Section 63 of the Criminal Justice and Immigration Act 2008 banning 'extreme' pornography, said today: "This proves that censorship and restriction of individual liberties in England is occurring because of members of the government's personal hang-ups."

The focus comes as the home secretary faces calls for her resignation over her husband's use of public money to pay for blue movies.

The oldest son of Dame Vivienne Westwood accused Jacqui Smith of embarking on a "crusade on the sex industry", which, he said, "is not to protect people but to protect herself".

Bookmakers today made Ms Smith odds-on to be out of her job by the end of the year.

"This Labour puritan's restriction of individual freedom has been so that she can restrict her own husband," Mr Westwood added.

"She has attacked prostitution, lap-dancing clubs and pornography in her role as home secretary, and now we know why."

To read politics.co.uk's coverage of the extreme porn law, including comment and analysis, click here.

The justice bill, which came into force on 1st January, gave the government unprecedented powers to police previously private sexual activities.

Last year, opponents of the new laws, including at least two lords, criticised the banning of possession of "an extreme pornographic image", saying it would criminalise thousands of previously law-abiding people who have a harmless taste for unconventional sex.

"The government gets away with murder when it comes to legislating about our sexual behaviour because we are a strait-laced nation and far too many of us are embarrassed about talking about sex," Westwood said last year.

He lead a protest outside Westminster along with a "chain gang" of bound and gagged models and activists from the Consenting Adult Action Network (CAAN) against what campaigners believed was an unnecessary restriction on adults' sexual choices.

A spokesperson for CAAN has said: "Over the last ten years, government has been intruding ever more actively into what adults may or may not do with other consenting adults in the privacy of their own bedrooms simply for having sexual tastes that are unacceptable to the prudes in power."

But campaigners against extreme pornography argued the bill was needed to help prevent violent sexual crimes.

Liz Longhurst, mother of Jane Longhurst who was killed by Grahan Courtts in 2003, argued there was a strong link between portrayals of violence in X-rated films, and the real thing.

Coutts's trial heard how for eight years before the murder in 2003 he had trawled the internet looking for pictures of women being strangled and raped.

"They made him feel he wasn't alone in his preoccupation. I think before he found like-minded people on the internet, he believed he was the only person with those thoughts. But when the internet came along, he saw there were all these websites, so he thought it was all right to have these fantasies," Mrs Longhurst told reporters in January.

There is no indication that the films Ms Smith claimed for on her expenses were violent pornography.

What do you think?

Name 

Location 

Email 

Comment 

Enter the text shown to the right

User comments...

  • "What a lame country - screechy reactions like Ben Westwood's to women having some chance of escape from violation in the sex industry, run through every bit of current media. I'm an alien living in this planet. Everyone's so logic- devoid in their attempts to uphold the patriarchy, leave this woman alone you freaks. "

    annoyed (Exeter) Posted: 30/03/2009 23:37:14

  • "I agree that the "exteme porn" laws are dreadful and nonsensical. However, this latest Jacqui Smith debacle is pretty unrelated. I don't see anything necessarily wrong with her claiming a few jizz flicks on expenses. I guess a bit of sleaze is good because it hopefully limits the extent to which the powers that be can dictate what us consenting adults can and can't get up to in out own time, but they still do it."

    Bill Carr (UK) Posted: 02/04/2009 03:07:06

  • "She can watch whatever she wants, her husband too just don't ask me to pay for it! Really not interested in what they get up to at home but they don't even have the decency to pay for it themselves? That just shows how much they take the piss out of taxpayers. "

    Paula (East Yorkshire) Posted: 06/04/2009 14:34:34

  • "I'm a little disgusted that anyone can take an isolated case of sexual violence and relate it to pornography. There is NO CONCRETE EVIDENCE that pornography, even fetish pornography is linked to violent crimes, such as rape or murder. Bondage is a FANTASY. Anyone who takes it more than that, is obviously sick and there's something psychologically disturbed going on there. Again, it has NOTHING to do with pornography. Individuals who make such accusations are just trying to point the finger at something easy to avoid working on the real problem. In addition, the only reason there is "violation" in the sex industry, is because society perpetuates it. They TELL women that it is demeaning, so we feel helpless. It's just another way for western culture to take away sexual power from women through out-dated Puritan views. I am equally disgusted that government in the UK is infiltrating into the personal lives of their citizens to such an extent. Censorship of sex is possibly the most idiotic, most offensive, most OPPRESSIVE thing that a society can do. We (USA and western European culture) need to see sex as something natural, and it's simply not the business of petty, ill-tempered women with no confidence to decide what goes on in my bedroom. They are getting away with murder! I live in the USA. We are horribly sexually oppressed and extremely hypocritical in how we project sexuality in our society. However, this is EXTREMELY low for the UK. You guys are supposed to be SUPERIOR TO US, for goddsake. We view the UK as more contemporary, open-minded, and accepting of sex. I originally read about this dilemma in an American issue of PENTHOUSE last month, in which the nee law in question was deeply criticized. This is JOKE!!! It's 2009! This is taking away civil liberties, individualism, and the world's respect for this governmental system. My real question is how does a woman like this get into power to begin with? I feel like that should be pondered upon more than the different ways to brainwash the public. As one of the signs held up in Westwood's protest last month. "1984 is NOW"; and honestly, it makes me SICK."

    Sara (Midwest, USA) Posted: 20/04/2009 09:42:33

Election Video Manifestos

politics.co.uk's Opinion Formers set out to present their manifesto "wish lists" to the next generation of MPs and ministers ahead of the General Election in 2010.

Dogs Trust UK Election Manifesto Video

Dogs Trust give us their 2010 General Election Manifesto video in which they give us their views on stray dogs and battery farms and the need for compulsory microchipping.

Check out more Opinion Former election video manifestos here

politics.co.uk Blog channel

Political blogs are likely to play a crucial role in the battle between the political parties in the upcoming general election. So we at politics.co.uk decided to give our readers a guide to those blogs that we think are worth a read. Check out the new politics.co.uk blogs channel and explore the hundreds of UK political blogs we have featured here.

politics.co.uk blog

Read the latest blog posts from the editorial team at politics.co.uk

UK's No.1

We are the UK's leading dedicated political news website. Find out how you can get your message across to our audience of opinion leaders and policy makers.

Newsletters

Stay up to date with the goings on both in UK politics and on politics.co.uk by signing up to our daily newsletter, public affairs newsletter and jobs bulletin.

Public Affairs Jobs

Check out politics.co.uk's new jobs section, for government, public sector and public affairs roles

Current Vacancies:

Featured Services

NewsManager

Offering Communications Professionals a solution to managing the systems required to undertake their work, NewsManager brings all of the components into one service.

DirectNews

DirectNews provides tailored news feeds for digital media and specialises in news content driven, sales and marketing solutions.

Search our services directory ...

Latest Opinion Former Press Releases

Declan Curry and Michelle Mone to speak at the National Housing Federation’s Housing Finance Conference

The National Housing Federation is delighted to announce the confirmation of two keynote speakers for its annual Housing Finance Conference, Declan Curry and Michelle Mone.