Gurkha 'despair' as minister sees off MPs

Gurkha campaigners outside parliament last weekGurkha campaigners outside parliament last week

Reddit

Stumble

 

Opinion Formers

Electoral Reform Society

The Electoral Reform Society is a voluntary organisation that campaigns for a better democracy, particularly through changes to our electoral system.

Find more Opinion Formers in this category:

 

Related News

Ashdown claims senior Labour figures could defect

Former Liberal Democrats leader Paddy Ashdown has claimed key Labour party figures have signalled they would defect to the Liberal Democrats if the party becomes too left wing.

Senior Labour figures could defect to Liberal Democrats, says Paddy Ashdown
 

Related Analysis

Comment: The problem with Labour is it doesn't believe in anything

If you look closely at what Blunkett's been saying, you can spot the reasons Labour is falling apart – and even why British politics feels so tarnished.

The problem with Labour is it doesn't believe in anything

Tuesday, 05, May 2009 02:30

By politics.co.uk staff

Joanna Lumley has claimed she was shocked at the government's inaction following last week's Commons defeat on Gurkhas.

The actress and campaigner's comments came as she gave evidence to the home affairs committee, which had been hearing from immigration minister Phil Woolas.

He told MPs the government was committed to clearing the backlog of 1,500 applicants by the end of May.

And he insisted an analysis of disputed figures over how many Gurkhas would be eligible for entry would be completed by the end of June.

Mr Woolas insisted the desire to allow Gurkhas into the country had to be balanced with "restrictions" of "finance and law".

"You cannot play politics with the law or with the money," he said. "Political populism doesn't change the facts."

Last week the government suffered only its fourth defeat over whether Gurkhas who retired before 1997 deserved full settlement rights in Britain.

Labour MP Martin Salter was particularly critical of the government's stance. "It's impossible to conceive that the government could have made a bigger pig's ear of this," he said.

Ms Lumley, having listened to Mr Woolas' evidence, expressed her own frustration after ministers had departed.

She accused the government of using "scare tactics" when citing a potential figure for new Gurkha settlers in Britain of 36,000.

And she added: "We stick to our guns and say [we demand] parity with Commonwealth soldiers. I don't know who else I go to now. We've been to the high courts, we've been to the people and press, we've even been to the parliament. If that's not enough, where do we go to?"

During the session Ms Lumley revealed she had received a letter of support from a senior member of the royal family. She declined to say which one.

What do you think?

Name 

Location 

Email 

Comment 

Enter the text shown to the right

User comments...

  • "I agree with Miss Lumley, the people have spoken, Gordon Brown and his ministers still don't appear to be listening. Perhaps they'll finally get the message after the next election when, hopefully this corrupt, dishonest government will be out of office. Although as we have an elective dictatorship in this country these people will still be walking off into the sunset with a substantial pension paid out of the "little peoples taxes"! Didn't Gordon Brown say there should be no reward for failure recently or doesn't that apply to politicians? Submitted by cheated Equitable life policyholder."

    Timothy J.Oates (ABINGDON/UK) Posted: 05/05/2009 15:39:09

  • "Our Government seems fit to fill our country with sponging imigrants , a minority of which are plotting to distroy us . Yet they wish to turn their back on the brave Gurkhas who have given their all in the defence of our land. Shame on Gordon Brown and the Labour Government "

    Craig Caldwell (Glasgow) Posted: 05/05/2009 22:28:32

  • ""Labour MP Martin Salter was particularly critical of the government's stance. "It's impossible to conceive that the government could have made a bigger pig's ear of this," he said." Salter has made a pigs ear of this one by making all this bluster but when it came to the vote in Parliament he abstained. If the government made a pigs ear of it he is the one who has gone down like a lead balloon over his actions."

    Andrew Tattersall (Strasbourg) Posted: 06/05/2009 13:42:31

Election Video Manifestos

politics.co.uk's Opinion Formers set out to present their manifesto "wish lists" to the next generation of MPs and ministers ahead of the General Election in 2010.

politics.co.uk Blog channel

Political blogs are likely to play a crucial role in the battle between the political parties in the upcoming general election. So we at politics.co.uk decided to give our readers a guide to those blogs that we think are worth a read. Check out the new politics.co.uk blogs channel and explore the hundreds of UK political blogs we have featured here.

politics.co.uk blog

Read the latest blog posts from the editorial team at politics.co.uk

UK's No.1

We are the UK's leading dedicated political news website. Find out how you can get your message across to our audience of opinion leaders and policy makers.

Newsletters

Stay up to date with the goings on both in UK politics and on politics.co.uk by signing up to our daily newsletter, public affairs newsletter and jobs bulletin.

Public Affairs Jobs

Check out politics.co.uk's new jobs section, for government, public sector and public affairs roles

Current Vacancies:

Featured Services

NewsManager

Offering Communications Professionals a solution to managing the systems required to undertake their work, NewsManager brings all of the components into one service.

DirectNews

DirectNews provides tailored news feeds for digital media and specialises in news content driven, sales and marketing solutions.

Search our services directory ...

Latest Headlines

Ministers condemned in cash for influence sting

Two former-ministers who appeared to be prepared to accept cash for exerting their influence have been criticised by their former colleagues today.

Byers is under severe scrutiny following the sting operation for the Dispatches programme

Speakers Corner