Beauty spots could become wind farms

Ed Miliband didn't rule out building wind farms on Areas of Outstanding National BeautyEd Miliband didn't rule out building wind farms on Areas of Outstanding National Beauty

Reddit

Stumble

 

Opinion Formers

Countryside Alliance

The Countryside Alliance’s purpose is to campaign for the countryside, country sports and the rural way of life.

Find more Opinion Formers in this category:

 

Related News

Rural areas face financial exclusion

Around a million people living in rural areas in the UK face high levels of financial exclusion according to a government report which seeks to deal with the issue.

Rural areas face financial exclusion
 

Related Analysis

Sketch: Bronco 8, MPs 0

It was an utterly absurd, completely British, scene.

John Gummer before he met his bucking downfall

Monday, 06, Jul 2009 10:09

By Alice Cannet

Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty (AONB) like the Lake District national park could be the sites of new energy infrastructure including wind farms, Ed Miliband has suggested.

Asked if wind farms could be considered in AONBs, Mr Miliband said: "In exceptional circumstances, it may be possible for some limited development to take place without unacceptable impacts on these important sites."

The energy and climate change secretary commented on the Campaign to Protect Rural England's (CPRE) new blog in a response to a list of questions on energy, climate change and landscape.

CPRE had invited the public to visit their blog to participate in the debate. The new blog enabled voters to ask Mr Miliband questions which he will answer by the end of the month.

Mr Miliband was asked to clarify his position on wind farms after he said it should "be socially unacceptable to be against wind turbines in your area - like not wearing a seatbelt or driving past a zebra crossing."

In a new statement on CPRE's blog, Mr Miliband moved away from his former stance, saying "there are some places where wind farms may not be suitable".

CPRE contested the government's promise to cut down greenhouse gas emissions after it did not rule out coal mining, a huge source of emissions, adding pressure on Mr Miliband to justify this.

Ed Miliband explained in his reply that coal mines could remain provided they were "environmentally acceptable" but shifted the responsibility on the Department for Communities and Local Government (DCLG), which is in charge of planning applications for new coal mining sites.

He said: "There is a value to the country in maintaining access to coal reserves, as long as it's environmentally acceptable, and this can include shallow coals suitable for surface mining."

There were ten questions to the climate and climate change secretary on the blog and CPRE's chief executive, Shaun Spiers, insisted: "These questions aren't going to go away. They are asked every time a new wind farm is proposed."

"And communities asked to accept intrusive new renewable energy infrastructure such as wind farms will ask how serious the government is about reducing greenhouse gas emissions when it is still prepared to allow carbon intensive opencast mining."

On wind farms, Mr Piers said: "Onshore wind farms have a role to play – but only where they will not cause unacceptable damage to the countryside and where they have been subject to proper democratic planning scrutiny.

Mr Piers concluded: "We see this blog as the start of a discussion with the government on these very important issues."

Mr Miliband's department will publish a renewable energy strategy this summer which will set out estimates figures for onshore wind farms contribution to total renewable energy production.

What do you think?

Name 

Location 

Email 

Comment 

Enter the text shown to the right

User comments...

  • "I am still waiting for any real world evidence that onshore wind substitutes for any significant amount of CO2 from thermal power stations. Other countries have long had huge wind capacities but have only managed very small equivalent substitution. But we still get ridiculously optimistic forecasts from the likes of Ed Miliband. Forecasts that are not supported by power companies and grid utilities with real world experience of wind power generation."

    Gordon (Cornhill) Posted: 06/07/2009 17:57:13

  • "Each wind farm needs the equivalent in fossil fuel back up to cope with variability. The Danish experiment has proven that having wind does not reduce Co2 since having wind Danish Co2 has increased. Because they have minimal access to gas they have needed to ramp coal fired generation up and down as required. It is also true that in their history the wind has never blown at the right time so the majority of power generated by wind has needed to be given away at zero price to Norway and Germany. So the result is that Denmark has burnt more coal, produced more Co2 and attained no personal benefit from having wind power in any way whatsoever in terms of energy generation. The only benefit to Denmark from wind is 30,000 Danish jobs sustained by the manufacture of them. There preference now is to burn straw, first because it provides base load which wind cannot and second its reliability and will keep the lights on whereas wind is not. The touchstone is, would you allow your child to undergo open heart surgery in a hospital powered by the wind. If having wind means burning more fossil fuel just so that you can have a good warm feeling and be prepared to ignore the absolute facts then good luck but burning more gas just to have wind doesnt conserve natural resources for our children or our childrens children which is what I thought conservation meant. What it does mean is that we consign our children to the stone age having to cook food over an open fire started by rubbing sticks together and I am sure that they will thank us for that. Milliband is a fruitcake politician, devoid of intellect and long on rhettoric and we all know that empty vessels make the most noise. The Ceo of E.ON has stated clearly that if the UK wants wind power then it will need to stump up a further £100 billion to provide fossil fuel back and then another £30 billion to install a new grid system that is able to cope with the extreme variability of wind. Remember also that as of now the maximum efficiency of installed wind power is about 15% of its maximum rated capacity, wind people only ever talk about rated capacity not actual efficiency. Off shore wind is far less because of the hostile environment, at least 25% of capacity is out of service either broken down or under repair and when the wind isnt blowing to counteract the effects of the hostile environment they reverse the flow of electricity to keep the turbines turbing otherwise the level of corrosion increases dramatically reducing their half life from ten years to as little as 7 so in effect if you spend £100 bn on off shore wind, you get to spend it again in 15 years and without fossil fuel they die anyway because how do you service something 3 miles high in the Atlantic with no diesel for the tug and crane? Wind farm enthusiasts need to take an object lesson in practicality rather than indulging in fantasy."

    David Wells (Lincolnshire) Posted: 08/07/2009 19:47:57

Election Video Manifestos

politics.co.uk's Opinion Formers set out to present their manifesto "wish lists" to the next generation of MPs and ministers ahead of the General Election in 2010.

Dogs Trust UK Election Manifesto Video

Dogs Trust give us their 2010 General Election Manifesto video in which they give us their views on stray dogs and battery farms and the need for compulsory microchipping.

Check out more Opinion Former election video manifestos here

politics.co.uk Blog channel

Political blogs are likely to play a crucial role in the battle between the political parties in the upcoming general election. So we at politics.co.uk decided to give our readers a guide to those blogs that we think are worth a read. Check out the new politics.co.uk blogs channel and explore the hundreds of UK political blogs we have featured here.

politics.co.uk blog

Read the latest blog posts from the editorial team at politics.co.uk

UK's No.1

We are the UK's leading dedicated political news website. Find out how you can get your message across to our audience of opinion leaders and policy makers.

Newsletters

Stay up to date with the goings on both in UK politics and on politics.co.uk by signing up to our daily newsletter, public affairs newsletter and jobs bulletin.

Public Affairs Jobs

Check out politics.co.uk's new jobs section, for government, public sector and public affairs roles

Current Vacancies:

Featured Services

NewsManager

Offering Communications Professionals a solution to managing the systems required to undertake their work, NewsManager brings all of the components into one service.

DirectNews

DirectNews provides tailored news feeds for digital media and specialises in news content driven, sales and marketing solutions.

Search our services directory ...

Latest Opinion Former Press Releases

Declan Curry and Michelle Mone to speak at the National Housing Federation’s Housing Finance Conference

The National Housing Federation is delighted to announce the confirmation of two keynote speakers for its annual Housing Finance Conference, Declan Curry and Michelle Mone.