MPs criticise absence of home-school regulation

Parents who educate their child at home face greater regulation and monitoring from local councils
Parents who educate their child at home face greater regulation and monitoring from local councils
 
 
 

Related Analysis and Comment

Sketch: Quentin Davies' blustering masterclass

Defence minister Quentin Davies showed how nothing quite beats bluster as he bristled his way through an absurd Commons committee grilling.

Quentin Davies appeared before the Commons' defence committee

Wednesday, 16, Dec 2009 12:01

By Emmeline Saunders

Parents who teach their children at home should be more closely monitored by local authorities, a group of MPs have said.

The children, schools and families (CSF) committee criticised the government over the lack of regulation in home-educating.

Committee chair Barry Sheerman said the onus must be on local councils and agencies to know which children are in school, which are home-schooled and the ones who are missing, but stressed that council workers should not take on a "more overt safeguarding role".

"If a balance is to be struck between parental rights and guaranteeing that all children have access to a good education, local authorities must work positively and cooperatively with home-educating families," he said.

Between 45,000 and 50,000 children are taught from home in England, but a lack of basic data means local councils urgently require improved methods to get detailed information, the report stated.

Opponents of home schooling have argued the absence of regulation could leave some children isolated, without a varied and 'proper' education, or even at risk of harm.

The committee has called for the introduction of a "more precise" definition of what constitutes a suitable education, with local authorities working closely with families to "strengthen parental responsibility" in providing their children with a 'quality' education.

A voluntary "light-touch" registration scheme for home-educating families has been recommended by the committee, with a review after two years to see if a compulsory registration programme would be viable.

Data would then be shared with other local authorities, such as the police, NHS trusts and HM Revenue and Customs.

It was suggested that parents should provide a "statement of educational approach" to inform local authorities what they intended to teach their child. This would be supplemented with yearly meetings with council officers.

The report also criticised the government's "unfortunate" handling of the earlier Badman review into elective home education, saying the CSF department had not paid "sufficient attention" to the matter to offering effective support and services to home-educating families, and had underestimated the cost of training council workers.

What do you think?

Name 

Location 

Email 

Comment 

Enter the text shown to the right
  • "Thank you for your comment."

    Raquel () Posted: 16/12/2009 01:43:05

  • "Thank you for your comment."

    Sarah () Posted: 16/12/2009 01:49:04

  • "Thank you for your comment."

    Rachel Roth () Posted: 16/12/2009 07:17:51

  • "Thank you for your comment."

    Linda () Posted: 16/12/2009 10:11:13

  • "Thank you for your comment."

    Jonathan () Posted: 16/12/2009 10:47:26

  • "Thank you for your comment."

    stephen () Posted: 16/12/2009 22:25:26

  • "Thank you for your comment."

    Eric Potter () Posted: 16/12/2009 23:21:28

  • "Thank you for your comment."

    Firebird () Posted: 26/12/2009 15:36:41

  • "Thank you for your comment."

    Conor Thompson () Posted: 05/02/2010 12:04:11

More News

David Cameron's father passes away

David Cameron's father died today, shortly after he arrived at the hospital to see him.

David Cameron is flying to France to be with his ill father

Phone hacking: Speaker announces Commons debate

Downing Street's hopes of the phone hacking row being put to bed have crumbled to dust after the Speaker announced a Commons debate on the issue.

Bercow announced the decision to hold a debate after PMQs

Lawyers withhold Tomlinson post-mortem

A third post-mortem of Ian Tomlinson, the man who died after being pushed to the ground at G20 protests last year, has been withheld from the coroner.

Video footage shows Ian Tomlinson falling to the ground

Pressure grows for reform of murder law

The pressure for Britain's murder law to become more flexible is growing, after the second director of public prosecutions (DPP) in a row came out in favour of reform.

Public prosecutors are advocating radical changes to murder laws

Free Newsletter

Sign up to politics.co.uk's free daily newsletter and never miss a key political news story again.


Opinion Formers

British Security Industry Association New Government Manifesto

Click on the video below to begin playing, or view the full size video here. Get Adobe Flash player

British Motorcyclists Federation (BMF)

motorcycle, motorcyclists, biker, motorbikes, bikes, safety for motocyclists, bikes, transport, road

Breast Cancer Care

, breast cancer, mastecomy, cancer research, cancer treatment, health, cancer, illness, cancer treat

Chamber of Shipping

, shipping, ships, tankers, ships, trade, finance, business, oil tankers, transport, transportation,

Building Societies Association (BSA)

, building society, demutualisation, building societies,

Council of Mortgage Lenders (CML)

Countryside Alliance

, fox hunting, countryside alliance, fox hunts, foxes, shooting, angling, country sports, field spor

Crisis

, housing, homelessness, rough sleepers, begging, beggars, Crisis, homeless, charity, houses, living

National Housing Federation

housing, housing associations, sheltered housing, council houses, affordable housing, Local Area Agr

International Fund for Animal Welfare (IFAW)

, animal rights, animal welfare, circus, zoo, whaling, fox hunting, animal cruelty, foxes, whales, f

Intellect

, cssa, federation of electrical industries, computer, computers, software, information technology,

Search for Opinion Formers related to Education