How coalition bitterness threatens Lords reform

By

I thought the list of reasons why the coalition's Lords reform bill is doomed couldn't get any longer. The death by a thousand cuts argument still holds firm. Then there's historical precedent, and the link with boundary changes, and the money factor.

The last week or so has seen a new factor emerge: coalition bitterness.

It didn't have to be this way. It was a deliberate decision of Cameron and Clegg to give the deputy prime minister direct responsibility for constitutional reform. That is backfiring for the DPM, whose unpopularity among Tory backbenches has plummeted to new lows following last week. They despise him for having refused to back culture secretary Jeremy Hunt over the BSkyB takeover bid row, and - at last week's meeting of the 1922 committee - were reportedly in fighting talk mode when the legislation receives its timetable motion next month

.This is critical because otherwise the government won't stand a chance of getting the bill through the Commons and Lords before next spring. A timetable motion limits the amount of time legislation has to be debated for; opponents of the bill would rather give MPs an opportunity to engaging in some filibustering foot-dragging that could leave parliament's schedule - and the government's broader legislative agenda - clogged up for months.

A series of concessions are expected to be made when the bill is presented to Cabinet members at the end of the month. Most importantly, the legislation is set to be reworked so that it specifically outlines the primacy of the Commons over the Lords. This has been the biggest single gripe of MPs and peers scrutinising the bill for months, so it makes sense that the biggest retreat should come here. The other big retreat could be over the constituency sizes of the new, elected upper House: MPs are fed up as it is with members of the European parliament meddling in their seats, without another elected representative getting in the way. The bigger ministers can make the electorates of the reformed upper House, the better. Minister Mark Harper has argued against this repeatedly over the months, but could now be ready to give ground - if that's what it takes to make progress.

Political news to your inbox

Fill in your details to receive Politics.co.uk's brand of informed, in-depth and independent coverage of Westminster to your inbox

Hot topics

Britain's great energy debate

How the power gets to Britain's homes in the next century remains a matter of deep controversy

As the next general election begins to loom over the horizon, the debate over Britain's future energy policy mix is starting to hot up - and nothing seems guaranteed.

The Heathrow third runway debate

Heathrow's third runway is just one of many options

There won't be a final decision on Britain's long-term aviation strategy until after the 2015 general election - but an aggressive national debate is already underway.

Opinion Former Events

MRSA Action UK Annual Memorial Event

Families will pay tribute and remember those lost to MRSA and healthcare associated infections at Westminster Abbey on Thursday 13th June 2013

BSIA: Information Destruction Exhibition & Conference 2013

Following the great success of the BSIA's Information Destruction Conference and Exhibition in May 2012, we are pleased to annouce that the event is returning again in June 2013. This one-day conference and exhibition is aimed at key decision makers in organisations that carry out the secure destruction of confidential material.